So I was reading about Henry VIII (No, I truly don’t get this, but not only is No Will But His selling better than anything else, I have, the sales are accelerating.)
While the Baen books still have priority, I’m going to try to – G-d willing and this week being atypical for the year (I am better, thank you, and no longer living in the bathroom) – find enough time this year to write the other queens. (On the good side, I’ve done two of those books. One took me 2 weeks and one 3 days, so…)
But it’s been years since I read anything about Tudor England and there have been new books. So I’ve been reading about Henry VIII because frankly I haven’t been up to reading fiction this week.
Anyway, so every author agrees Henry VIII as a young man was a true renaissance man, good at everything and so very good looking. And every author wonders what dread disease caused him to turn not just into a murderous tyrant, but a stupid murderous tyrant in old age.
Except if you dig in you find that when his dumbest moves were made was after he’d killed his two ministers, first the great one and then his apprentice. (Wolsey and Cromwell.) Which brings us to… was he really that brilliant or were they great at manipulating him.
But surely – say you – he composed music, he wrote poems, he wrote theological dissertations, for crying out loud.
Except that Thomas Moore put the finishing touches on the “theological dissertations” – were they “finishing touches” or book doctoring? And at least one book casts doubt on whether he had the same kind of help with his music and, let’s face it, his sonnets to Anne Boleyn are remembered because of their very unfortunate romance, not because he was another Thomas Wyatt. (And for all I know Thomas Wyatt helped him “with the finishing touches” too.)
While I read, I started getting this incredibly familiar feeling. “They tell me he’s a genius, but there’s really no proof and no one would dare have said anything else in writing because he was an absolute monarch.” It could be argued in that way they fed the ego of a man who was just a man till he became, ultimately, a monster.
And while we’re at it, when the same forces apply in a supposed democratic republic that applied in Henry VIII’s absolute monarchy, something must be done. I’m just saying. We’ve seen this movie many times from Henry VIII to the Sun King to Kim Il Jung. It always ends in blood. And it’s rarely the blood of those responsible for making the people suffer. I’m just saying it’s time for America to be exceptional again.
Oh, and while on that, when Henry VIII died he left England near bankrupt. I was snorting with laughter at an author who couldn’t understand why Henry VIII stayed “protestant” – in the most Catholic way possible – after his first two wives died, instead of submitting to Rome. Sigh. Apparently this is an historian who believes the ledger part of the reign isn’t history. He couldn’t go back to Rome because he’d dissolved the monasteries and pillaged their wealth in land, houses and rents. DUH. And then he still took the kingdom into penury. Good thing he didn’t have a printing press he could run at will to create fiat money, uh?
And speaking of other people who have been told what they wanted to hear or what other people wanted to be true until they’re drinking their own ink and completely out of touch with reality – here’s a few more examples:
Like all monsters of legend, Bill Blasio is attacking New York City. Only the Castro-admirer was elected to lead it. Yes, I know most people there drink their own ink, too. They’re too wealthy and comfortable and think reality no longer applies to them. But there is something wonderful and special about the city. Try to go see it before it becomes Detroit.
As for the Ship of Fools in search of global warming, who got stuck in ice – no matter how much the tv stations hide it and no matter how much they call the occupants “tourists” the gig is up. It’s like the summer of recovery, guys. You’re telling people digging out from under snow they’re having a heat wave. Your climate refugees failed to show up. Most of us know we’re not stuck in a tropical paradise. Oh, and most of us know, too, that the Earth was much warmer than this before, sometimes when there weren’t humans. You can indoctrinate people going through the schools, but in time they get out and the scales fall from their eyes. And sometimes, if you push hard enough, you create people like me, who went through a much more biased system than even you have managed. Sure those who are like me will be one in a hundred, but all the same, think on it. Consider telling the truth now and then.
But this – this is an example of drinking your own ink that leaves us absolutely breathless. I’m linking to the Chicks on the Right Holy Mother of Whack, instead of to the original article. You’re free to read that, but TRUST me, you’ll be dumber for it.
I’m not going to go into EVERYTHING that’s wrong with the original article – a cry for psychiatric help if I ever heard one – but will just point out the person seems to think of evolution as a god. However we’re formed, we can tell for if it hurts or not that it is or isn’t meant to be used in some way. Older son who is a fully trained biologist tells us that the hymen is actually a “seal for freshness” not in the sex sense, but because it keeps most disease-causing germs away, until the woman is of reproductive age, which increases the chances she’ll reproduce and pass on the gene for it. (This btw, explains why women in the middle ages were kept from strenuous exercise, which is known to rupture the hymen. They didn’t have antibiotics. Another myth of male supremacy exploded. Sad.)
The sad – truly sad – thing is that this psychological cry for help is not that individual. For instance, while on a panel with one of the glittery whoo has who later plunged into the SFWA kerfuffle, I watched her try to articulate the same argument. She was CERTAINLY sure that men only had sex with women to impregnate them (wait, what?) And that this was the primary purpose of rape.
Don’t get me started.
When a significant portion of the population gets this far away from reality and CAN live, our society is so wealthy that most of us can afford to be like Henry VIII completely divorced from reality.
The question is – can it go on?
I think it can, but I think that the gods of the copybook headings will make a comeback tour before we’re on the right course again.
WELCOME Instapundit Readers and thank you Glenn for the link!