This post comes from the confluence of two completely unrelated events: people wondering why the men of Great Britain haven’t risen yet (with pitchforks and torches) and the fact I’ve been reading a British mystery series set in WWI, which to my eye (as a former European) has pretty accurate inter-class relationships.
First in defense of British men, I have to say that you can’t judge them too harshly, because you have absolutely no idea what they’re doing to resist or how hard they’re doing it. And won’t actually know until and unless the whole thing tips into the pot. Which, as with us a few months ago, and with us again should the left manage to cheat their way into power at midterms, I hope it doesn’t do for their sakes. And I hope it gets corrected another way, for their sakes. Look, vengeance is extremely satisfying… in theory. In reality it hits a lot of innocents, and leaves those who exerted revenge coarser, tired and guilty. And the last will come out in various truly awful ways, because humans express guilty by doubling down so as to retroactively justify their misdeeds.
But the truth is we don’t know what British men are doing. Can’t know. The same veil of secrecy from their government that keeps most of them from knowing how bad things actually are, keeps us from knowing what they’re doing. To understand the veil of secrecy, cast your minds back just four years ago, when you could get your account shut (like Out of Darkness) on Facebook and Twitter for posting a lot of anti-lockdown memes. And you never got it back. This was a time when I — I who am pretty far down the blogging ecosystem — lived in fear of both debanking and IRS shenanigans. (This last was actually tried, not very expertly, but tried.)
They live with this, but taken to eleven. You can actually get arrested for sharing the mildest of the memes I share here on Saturdays.
The thing is this type of control doesn’t actually suppress dissent. What it does is suppress the knowledge that every person on the verge of losing their mind with rage is not in fact alone. Which makes it harder to have any kind of collective action. It was working here, and it’s working there. People, even people who know the controls on expression or how corrupt the vote is, default to assuming it’s all hunky dory. I keep seeing people talk about how NYC voted for a Muslim communist, or how California is voting for this or that, when the most trivial analysis will show that fraud is so thick on the ground their votes are immaterial. And sometimes the people saying they “voted” for this are the very same ones who denounced the fraud before.
Anyway, the problem with this control on opinion, on movement, on money, doesn’t actually indefinitely suppress bloody uprising. Instead it delays it and makes it inevitable that it will be an indiscriminate blood bath. And then people are very surprised and “never saw it coming.”
So we don’t know where on the pressure cooker scale Britain is, and we should do its men (and women. Oooh boy, the mothers should be boiling) the grace of assuming their acts of dissent and resistance are being kept in the dark.
BUT the whole thing of the abuse of girls by migrants is a puzzle to Americans. Both why the men haven’t boiled over, and why the “elites” allowed it to go on with a wink and a nudge. Same with the whole looking down on the people who are ACTUALLY THE NATIVE PEOPLES OF GREAT BRITAIN and treating newcomers and welcoming them as the most important social project ever.
This has layers. And the first is again, please to look in the mirror. There are entire areas we don’t talk about in the US. Yes, we do get very upset at migrants causing deaths of Americans (when we hear about them) even when by surname those Americans are the same ethnicity as the illegals that killed them. But beyond that, we — and by this I mean various ethnic groups — turn a blind eye on continuous murder and misbehavior because it’s worse to be considered “racist.” And thereby we cause the most racist result of all: that in which minorities aren’t expected to behave like civilized people and black on black, hispanic on hispanic, and for that matter black on hispanic and vice versa, crime happens continuously and no one pays attention, because apparently we don’t expect people who can tan to be fully functional human beings. And before you air your uneducated and eugenics-inspired nonsense about certain races not having the ability to behave like civilized people, let me point out the race — by actual genetic race markers — of most American blacks is Caucasian. Yes, they are that diluted. And also that before the great re-enslavement of the welfare state destroyed their families, their crime statistics were about the same as poor whites (as far as we can tell.) Also that as El Salvador is showing, Latins can behave in a civilized way, if you remove the small percentage of animals from their midst and lock them up. The fact we refuse to do this and that our elites preen themselves on not being “racist” by refusing to do this is one of the worst blots on us as a nation.
Which is part of the whole thing. Look, in this type of thing, we say race, they say class. The problem — and reading this mystery brought back almost forgotten memories of growing up in Europe — is that the upper classes in Europe treat the lower classes the way Americans — pardon me leftist Americans — treat black or latin Americans (even the ones born and brought up here): as a sort of troublesome pet whose behavior can’t be controlled, so we let the pet do it and get mad at anyone who points it out.
This is what was in Europe before the “migrants” started arriving by the boat full. The educated, technocratic class, more snobbish than any nobility of birth, looked at the lumpen masses of manual or service workers, and assumed they were a whole other class of humanity, not quite capable or willing to make an effort to be “civilized” or “educated.”
And yes, class really exists in Europe, in a way that Americans can’t process. I’m always highly amused when Americans write ANYTHING that involves nobility of birth, because there is subtle dissonances and an almost glaring inability to get it. The truth is it goes all the way down. Assumptions are made about people based on their class, treatment is completely different at an almost instinctive level, and people put up with things they shouldn’t because they know that’s what they’ll get based on their class. There is no ethics involved, because no one thinks about it. It’s sub-rational.
As an example, I like to point to our trip to France, in which the organizer, correctly, btw, though it would be more fun to travel from Paris to the Riviera by train, so we could see the countryside as we crossed it. So far so good. We paid for a first class, air-conditioned carriage. Only to find out minutes into the the hours long ride that the carriage’s air conditioning system was not working, the windows couldn’t be opened, and there were no blinds on the windows. As the temperature in the carriage rose to the hundreds, older people started passing out, and employees circulated giving us free water bottles.
Which is when I lost my mind. I and another American (might have been a member of my party or not. I don’t remember) got up and each stood at one end of the carriage holding the door open. Which rapidly cooled it to normal levels. Most of the people in the carriage — French — just stared at us. We spelled each other standing the doorway.
We came to find out that carriage has had broken air conditioning FOR YEARS and not only haven’t they taken it out of service, apparently no one ever thought to send employees to stand in the doorway keeping the air circulation going, even though the temperature in the carriage was at health endangering levels.
Why not? Well, because most of the people in the carriage are either lower or middle-middle class. Most probably middle-middle, giving paying for first class. The government has very little concern for them. They’ll get what they get and be happy. And they’re so used to it that it never occurred to them, spontaneously, to figure out a work around.
We get this a lot from the minorities who have long been pets of the left. They have become convinced they can’t solve things themselves, barring a massive overturn in the system. So it all becomes “the government should do something about it.”
In the same way, this was the situation in Britain before they started importing migrants by the boatload. The locals had become convinced over years — generations, just in the 20th century — of oppression by the governmental and functionary elites that they would be treated a certain way and there was nothing they could do about it. And meanwhile the upper classes and anyone in official authority got used to pushing people around and treating them like they’re the scum of the Earth (the mystery I’m reading.)
In America, even a filthy, obviously spaced out guy on drugs is a ‘gentleman’ and even a lady of the night is a “lady” in address. This shocked me profoundly when I was new here. It is not so abroad, practically anywhere else. (Maybe Canada, but they don’t mean it.) And yeah, even when said ironically, those count.
There is a different TEXTURE to this abroad.
And that was the situation before the migrants came in. I don’t know if this has been identified as a social phenomenon but the thing is the newcomers have no status in the society. While the lower classes have LOW status. So the migrants are immediately above.
Also, the upper classes in Europe are profoundly disappointed with the rest of the people in the country in a way that doesn’t echo in America. Look, sure, our “elites” (snort giggle) think badly of the rest of us and those on the coasts look down on the entire middle of the country. BUT that’s not by monolithic class, partly because we have enough church that the children of the middle of the country routinely become coastal elites.
I see this will need unpacking. Sorry, I’m fuzzy today. So, one of the conceits of the left in the twentieth century was that everyone would be educated and thereby become one of them.
Here, because of status churn, and people moving around and changing status constantly (it’s a very large country, and alas leftism is a positional good. Partly because of the assumption above) the leftist “elites” have the illusion this is happening.
In Europe, they’ve given up and of course as always when the plans fail, the fault is of those lower class yobs who refused to be uplifted. So there is resentment there, and hatred. Meanwhile, with the migrant newcomers, the “elites” don’t know that they too will refuse to be uplifted. They don’t KNOW there’s something intrinsically wrong with them. They “know” that about the native population.
So the migrants are immediately above and the native lower classes will get punished for attempting to break the hierarchy.
Layer on top of that the fact that ideological crap from America gets filtered by their newspapers and magazines and taken far more seriously there than it ever is here. (Another case of when America sneezes the rest of the world catches pneumonia.) As we found out through the BLM insanity, they drank up the academic intersectionality theories and are trying to apply them there. (This has led to Portugal developing an absolutely bizarre relation with gypsies of instance.)
And because leftism is a positional good that denotes you’re “well educated” this means that the elites are ALL IN on it. It’s how they prove their upper class status after all. Which means that those rubes on the lower seats trying to hold the poor migrants accountable for anything are just being prejudiced.
On top of this nauseating soup there’s the fact that multiculti requires you to tolerate if not approve of child marriage, polygamy, mistreatment of women and all the other “vibrant” cultural characteristics of the imported scum.
I have on twitter simultaneously read Indian accounts saying Suttee was a lie invented by the British (It wasn’t. There are first person reports from people of all nationalities) and that Suttee was a beautiful cultural practice we had no business disrupting. The flummery is palpable, but they can’t see it, because being “upper class” depends on NOT seeing it.
And therefore right now, the upper classes in Britain, who consider themselves scientific and technocrats, but are actually mostly jumped up functionaries and middle-managers with “excellent” educations, is now engaged in a to the death attempt to make the real world obey the insanity they were indoctrinated with, layered on the assumptions of their class-ranked society.
Literally to the death. Because when the picture in your head is completely at odds with reality, reality always wins. ALWAYS. It’s a tiresome thing but inevitable. And the longer and harder you try to impose the fantasy, the worse the breakage will be.
So, pray for Britain, if you’re the praying kind.
And keep an eye on us, because though we don’t have classes as such, we’ve let the “some people aren’t as capable as others” bullshit creep in. Which is a disservice to everyone, but particularly the “minorities” affected. And that means we’re ripe to let the same kind of nonsense reign. In fact, it’s started already.
Always remember you’re Americans: if the government is trying to boil you in a carriage in the sun, with windows that can’t be opened and the air-conditioning broken? Stand up and keep the doors open so air flows through.
Metaphorically speaking.
The lives you save are almost certainly everyone’s. Including yours.