I know I say this a lot, but I feel like I must say it again: we are all soaked in story, drenched in it. More so than any other generation or people in history.
I was lucky — eh — to live in a very old fashioned time, in a backward place until my teens, and not to have been particularly affluent.
How not particularly affluent? Well, there wasn’t much money for books. There was some, mind you. Just not much. And until I was eight we didn’t even a television, and the first time I went to the movies I was 12. Oh, there were other things. We did watch TV at friends and relatives places (which is how I loved The Saint.) And there were… radio soap operas. I couldn’t really listen to those regularly, because they usually were on over lunch, when I was either just arriving from school or just getting ready to go to school. (Due to lack of physical buildings enough for all the students (none had been built since my parents’ time, and there had been a marked migration from the provinces to the big city and big-city-adjacent (where we were. The village is now essentially part of the big city. Back then and through my life we became more and more of a suburb)) school was either 8 to 1:30 or 2 to 7.)
Even then, soap operas were so universally listened to, and so loud, to be heard over whatever else was going in the (usually very small) houses that while I was in intermediate school to which I took the bus, and walked down and up the village main street, I absorbed most of the story through just walking past door after door. And linked in the bits in between, because I couldn’t help it.
But still, there were vast times without story, and there was marked story-craving. I re-read books, a lot. I read everyone else’s books, including school books. I read old Reader’s Digests. I read everyone’s comic books. I read my older cousin’s romances. Yes, I read instructions for things I’d never owned and never would own. And I read the instructions for medicine I’d never take. As I’ve said before, I have a problem, and it is bad.
Even so, there were vast moments without stories and without words. Times when I had to cobble together stories in my mind, either of fantastic worlds, or of things happening in the village. This was not exactly gossip. I have a problem with names and faces, and older people (Really old people, like over 25) didn’t interest me at any rate. I just took pieces of their stories, and tried to figure out why, and what happened next.
Here’s the thing, even then, I was abnormally soaked in story. Because I probably spent a few hours each day listening to/reading/watching stories that I didn’t tell myself.
Evolutionarily I think this is crazy high for humans. Think of hunter gatherers (and remember that even that, evolutionarily is yesterday for our species. Okay, maybe last week. Agriculture is yesterday.) For most of human history, humans knew maybe five or six stories, which got told and retold, and sometimes “fixed” certain ways.
I know that at some point someone did um… Paleo-linguistic work on fairytales and found that Cinderella dates back to pre-history, as do a dozen others. Now, whatever you think of their methods, etc, this is not surprising. If you know more than a couple of cultures, even ones that supposedly were apart for a long time, you start picking stories or story elements that are the same.
Stories are part of what made humans very successful. Like, grandma’s told stories, so kids didn’t go traipsing in the woods and get eaten by a saber tooth, so they had kids and they told them stories, and their kids–
By substituting for experience, in a way that our brains seem really confused about — study after study indicates that we remember things we heard and PARTICULARLY watched as having happened to us and imprinting there with the emotion attached to it (which competent stories do) — stories can spare us dying in horrible, messy ways by showing “here be tigers” (Or really bad people. Or whatever.)
Also epics can sell a civilization. There’s reason to be Indo-European was not so much a blood tribe as a culture, sold through vast spoken sagas about how great the people were. Other people wanted to be part of that and imitated the culture and learned the sagas. Anyone who’s been abroad knows America as a leading purveyor of cool stories has the same effect. But because our stories aren’t always as high on America as they should be if it were a sane world, the rest of the world gets very funny stories about us. Stories that are completely wrong. And they still think we’re cool, so they try to imitate them.
No, seriously, there are probably gansters in Africa trying to wear their pants falling down their butt. And there are probably people who are criminals because they were sold by our music and movies that being criminals is cool. Such the power of story.
Because our main stream media is also a narrative, and a really loud one, and because it’s largely fiction and obsessive, there were BLM riots abroad in 2020. In some countries that are more minority-impaired than others this was particularly funny.
Also, I like to did myself violence laughing — and quoting Mr. 11B, “Had to go and breathe into a paper bag for a while” — when I ran into reports of people in Portugal having demonstrations after Trump’s election and screaming “Not my president.” Because… well, self obviously true, but why did they feel the need to get together in the middle of the street to yell it? Much less in front of the American Embassy? I’m sure the embassy knew it too. They didn’t need to be told.
I mean, guys, level-setting, we don’t even know — not even me, and I still have family there — who the three times refargin Portuguese President is. And if I knew and had some vague memory of his or his family, I might go “Oh, that sh*thead” but I wouldn’t feel the need to run around telling people “not my president.” As for the rest of you…. uh, except for some notable figures like Thatcher, say, do you even know who the BRITISH PM is? And mind, they’re closer to us culturally than anyone else around. I mean, I know Castreau is the — Premier? President? Prime Minister? Secretary general of affairs between middle-aged, married people? I don’t remember what they call their sh*thead in charge — Honcho is specialness in Canada. But honestly, I only know it because he pisses me off, and someone needs to draw a Hitler mustache on all his pictures. No, seriously. Including those in his family album. And I know Micro-Macron is in charge in France, because he’s unusually crazy even for a Frenchman. And don’t get me started on Obrador, in Mexico who is rapidly approaching “What if we shoved his nose in?” levels of annoyance. (Incidentally Obrar is the polite slang for “shitting” in Portuguese, so you know, in Portugal Obrador would be Shitter. I know, in Spanish it’s worker. BUT all the same, it pleases me in that indefinable way that linguistics sometimes do.)
However not ever, in the eve of ever, have I felt the need to shout: Not my president/premier/head honcho/idiot in special, much less in the streets.
Why did they do it? Because the narratives about the US are so special and compelling. (Also quite possibly the worst thing ones own citizens can say about a country, i.e. ficticious and slanderous, being produced by a minority that is oikophobic, Marxist and brain dead. But that’s something else.)
I mean, when I was little, in a place where (back then) an apartment building with four stories, the only one in the region, was known as “the high rise” I knew I had to grow up and live in a high rise. A real one. Because that’s how Americans live, and that was the future. (I told you they lie.)
And that was then. Now we’re really super-soaked (like a super-soaker with a back-pack) in story, to the point that we rarely pop out of it. I’m sitting here, typing this post, and ignoring the stories blaring over my husband’s computer. Because most songs are stories too.
More importantly, the primary forms of story, consumed by most of the US population, and what creates the texture of our minds are movies and games.
Look, even books have changed. And the books I like have changed. And what I require from books had changed.
Some of that is normal due to age, yes. But not all. And while I’d like to say I have gone towards wanting to consume more complex stories — bah, this isn’t true. On the contrary, I want my stories to go very fast.
Now there is nothing wrong with this, and there were always fast, quick-delivery tales.
However if you read stuff 20 years old, then 60, then 100, you’ll find it moves slower. The story moves slower. There are more things that are at least implied to happen in between the beginning and the satisfying (ah!) climax. The cigarette moment afterwards takes its own sweet time, too.
In stuff 100 or more years old, you often find entire mini novels or novellas in the middle of the novel, because someone sits down and tells a story that is transcribed in full. And yea, sometimes it applies to the main novel and sometimes it’s just…. local color? It’s bewildering.
This is because life felt slower, but more importantly, because people didn’t consume so many movies/games.
Movies and games telescope story. They have to. Movies particularly. Look, my favorite visual of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice (a slim and relatively low-event book) is the six hour A & E mini series.
Because telling a story visually takes a long long time to do it justice. Most movies can’t do that. Or we’d routinely go and sit in the theater for 14 hours at a go to see a movie of our average thriller novel.
What movies do instead is take short cuts and telescope things. And they use short hand. One of the short-hands is something happens “and the people all rise up.” (Happened never, in the history of ever. The closest is the Romanian Merry Christmas and even that was first slowly, then very fast. Unimaginably slowly, so most people in and our of the country didn’t see it happen.) Another, for romance — which to be fair, romance novels also use — is the look that binds them forever or the kiss that’s like no other kiss.
Movies gallop from “first indications that” through doing something about it to rushing to climax big fight, dropping into bed, whatever, to solution.
But real life is not like that. And because particularly movies get in the back of our brain as “lived experience”, we expect life to be like that. We expect the shortcuts to work. (The number of young women, starting when I was one, who aren’t sure they’re in love because his kiss isn’t electrical. Leading me to point out they’re not eels. And that storytellers lie. (More the first when I was young. I was a sarcastic little thing.))
It’s worse for movements that involve “all the people.” Heck, even if we ever got to the point of all marching “shoulder to shoulder” it would take decades to get there.
Let me see, the oppressed people and the evil rulers plot. You see the oppression, you see something outrageous like persecuting a folk hero. People start giving pissed looks and going armed. A popular ditty propagates about how the ruler sucks… toes. And suddenly revolution!
Never happened. In the history of ever.
Even in a small kingdom it would take 20 or 30 years from death of the folk hero, to “go.” And the “go” would involve multiple uncoordinated “gos” and about 90% of them would die aborning, or be stomped down.
In something the size of our nation-continent? Yeah. Look, I saw the crisis in commercial real estate coming 35 years ago. I could predict it. But obviously most people didn’t, because as in the time of Noah, they were marrying and being given in marriage, building increasingly ginormous and more expensive corporate headquarters. Without the Covidiocy they might not have been wrong, even, as it would probably only have landed 20 years from now. Instead, they are now shocked, shocked, shocked that there is a commercial real estate crisis. This is more the speed things happen.
The thing to remember is how even the history you learned in school is telescoped. The abuses and infringements leading to the revolution took a long time, and in the end only a small minority fought.
Why am I saying this? Because if I see another of those “my homies and I would already be stacking bodies” I’m going to come through the screen and slap someone. And no one, not even I, wants that, right?
But also because you need to remember the other side is just poisoned with story. More so than us, at least most of them, because most of them don’t read history, though they might sometimes watch “documentaries.” But those are really telescoped, too. On top of which they believe, even often without realizing it, in a prophetic narrative of “how things are supposed to go” which means they believe that you know “shoulder to shoulder, the people will win and establish the dictatorship of the proletariat.” They believe in it so much that even their own AstroTurf movements get eaten up whole as “signs of things to come.”
We’re jumpy, impatient, and those of us who are political addicts, are tired of the many infringements and abuses we see happening twice a day and three times on Sunday.
But they’re really jumpy, really impatient. The prophet is supposed to have wakened in his well, second coming of Marx is supposed to have happened. the dictatorship of the proletariat is supposed to already be in place. And those of us who are against them, are supposed to already have died off because we’re all so old (they really believe we’re all my dad’s generation, at least, maybe older.)
Instead, we’re getting more and more uppity. And we pretend to be much younger than them, how dare we. And no matter how many times they “shut up, they explain” we just talk back louder.
And they’re exasperated, enervated, sure of their eschatological truth, but not sure how to get there, much less how to interpret growing resistence. They’re the good guys. Don’t we want Utopia? How very dare we not only exist but remind them more of that every day?
This is why they’ve gone nuts, trying to retcon history, and change anything that doesn’t accord to their rather insane ideas. This is why they’re coming with crazy stuff like erasing the borders.
It’s not fraught because they’re winning. It’s fraught because we’re talking/fighting back, and that drives them out of their story-drunk minds. This is not how they ever thought it would go. they want to fix it, but they can’t, because reality can’t really be rewritten. Their efforts at “fixing things” only meet with more resistance.
Ladies, Gentlemen and small devious octopi, this is why it’s going to get very very bad. They’re reaching for everything they can think of, and most things no one would think of. I mean, most of them are movie tropes and complete insanity.
But they will do it. Like Jan 6th, was supposed to set off a minority (in their heads we’re a tiny and old minority) rebellion, easily put down, that would end all resistance. Instead, look at the mess they made…. For that matter, Covidiocy was a movie script from end to end, and if it had worked as in a story, right now they’d be receiving the thanks of a grateful populace. Instead, they’re mumbling about amnesty AND trying to restart it, and having no idea why none of it WORKS.
And instead of people marching shoulder to shoulder, they believe them less and less. How very dare? Stompy stompy stompy.
It’s going to get crazy. No, I mean, crazier than that. And a lot of it will hurt. Us and particularly people abroad. Because when America sneezes, the world will catch pneumonia.
But it will fix itself, because reality does that. Hopefully without it tipping into a “great simplification.” Maybe. Almost for sure without shoulder to shoulder, though a Romanian Merry Christmas is always possible.
First very slow, then precipitously fast. And everything they do makes the fast come closer.
Prepare, prepare prepare. And be not afraid.
We win, they lose.