Magic of Destruction by Bob the fool

If you are talking to a communist, or another religious believer in science or theory, they will want you to prove that you are correct if you say that they are practicing magical thinking. Since magical thinking was evolutionarily favored for reason of making reactions fast, without stopping to reason, evaluate proofs or logic, a magical thinker might be closed to the most obvious proofs that they are indulging in such.
‘Mathematical’ Preliminaries
Magical thinking exists in every human because it is a time saver. If you rigorously avoid magical thinking to question ‘is it bad to be eaten by the Tiger’, you get killed by the Tiger before you really get started. Exactly how time consuming it is to avoid magical thinking may not be apparent to everyone. This is partly because most people aren’t aware of performing magical thinking. Stopping such, can be very specialized training or experience, and the skill may not be very general. Another part, you may not actually have a very strong need to avoid magical thinking. There are circumstances where it is incorrect enough to matter, but that is not every time.
Nobody has enough time to avoid magical thinking for every single thing that they do. Sometimes you come out of the rain by habit, and it does not matter if you precisely evaluated how much you really needed to.
Generally, people who say that they never practice magical thinking are not introspecting properly, and have overlooked one or more elements of their thinking. Non magical thought processes are not perfect, and are expensive, so there is little real motivation for ensuring that they make up all of one’s thinking, and many motivations to prefer action over eternal naval gazing.
I think many of the motivations for believing one is always uses reason are magical thinking. Not understanding the limited utility of logic, and magically thinking that it perfectly answers all problems, might motivate a person to identify as being purely rational. (Logic depends on your assumptions. GIGO. If you do not have a habit of testing and retesting your assumptions, you have no idea where logic is misleading you.)
It is a ‘if you do not know who the mark is at the poker table, you are the mark’ problem. If you do not know where you tolerate magical thinking in your internal practices, it is buried somewhere that you do not realize.
Choice of magical thinking matters
What we call sanity and culture are downstream of individual selections of magical thinking. Which thoughts you repeat over and over, which thoughts emotionally draw you most strongly.
This stuff matters.
It can be hard to see by direct observation, hard to learn how to see, and hard to teach others to see.
State cult of the Aztec Triple Alliance is a perhaps sufficiently alien example to be useful. Mexica nobles of the Aztec Triple Alliance practiced pain magic in their daily lives. As in, they inflicted pain on themselves personally in ritual, and perceived the magic as real and productive. This directly overlaps with why they thought everything else they did was of real effect. This is why they did human sacrifices for everything. This is why they thought the sun would /die/ if they did not cut out enough hearts.
The choice matters
Christianity and Judaism are religions, and it is not generally required that we prove or explain that. There are most definitely specific patterns of magical thinking which are reinforced by those practices. Certain other patterns of magical thinking are basically omitted or discarded.
This has some critical implications missed in a lot of modern histographies. That lasting peaces are downstream of a consensus about magic in a culture which limits capricious beliefs that those other people over there can violate the peace agreement by witching you somehow.
Full discussion of comparison and contrast in magical thinking types is omitted here for space. Contrast Christianity versus liberation theology. Judaism versus those reform Jews who conflate leftism with the Law.
Christianity is a heresy of Judaism. Judaism had some very good mind genes, memes in the original sense. See, forex, the Samaritans. Those translated to the heresy of Christianity being itself fairly functional, and spawning some heresies that while perhaps wildly dysfunctional, may not be obviously so in their initial stages.
The most widespread heresies of Christianity are Islam and communism. (Islam hates Jews and Christians, because Jews and Christians have the information to show that the ‘prophecies’ of Jesus are pretty much all claims that Jesus is divine. Islam requires that Jesus make true prophecies, while also not being divine.)
Communism, in comparison, is playing a complicated motte and bailey game with ‘children of God’.
Communisms are cults of power, that use leadership magic to accomplish goals in this world, and play cheating games with what Christianity and Judaism would consider clear cut questions of good and evil.
(The party truth stuff, and inner and outer party stuff, is a wee bit diagnostic of magical thinking. Wishcasting word/consensus magic, and also fear of not participating in the ritual. Stalin would murder folks, capriciously and also purposefully. This made people afraid to verbally deviate from his proclaimed “wisdom.” This shows up in all the left, and means that they care much more about updating verbal positions to current expedient ones, then they do about the exercise of testing positions against each other. (One bit of evidence is how rarely the folks are willing to deviate on points.) From the Party’s perspective it is not possible to innocently be out of step, it is always deliberately an act of wrong doing that must be punished. Speech is part of the leadership magic that the party provides. The oft overlooked implication is that as long as this behavior continues, communist revolutions will always be ‘usurped’ and ‘stolen’ by ‘facists’. The communists give bad actor leaders too many tools for seizing and abusing power. This attracts a ton of bad actors to communist leadership positions.)
Destruction Magics
Communist theory/theology implicitly outlines the magical ideas practiced by repeating it, and by feeling it is important.
The split into victims and oppressors is pretty key. This is the cheating game with ‘children of God’, and with clear cut matters of good acts, and evil acts.
It is also a center of the magical thinking around destruction.
They do not say oppressors, victims, plus some people who are neither, and some people who are both. Oppressors and victims are defined necessarily as sets that are mutually exclusive, and exhaustive.
Consider high nobles of a German empire. Communist theory is that they are necessarily oppressors. One implication, peace consensus is not valid because the nobles are witching everyone else. Two, nobles must only be in a situation that is good for them by causing harm to others. There is no room in communist thought for circumstances in which ‘actually, it was mutually beneficial, and both parties profited from the arrangement’.
This is an aspect of zero sum ism.
(Christianity and maybe Judaism are opposite. Locally you can have from individual action good or bad results that are not balanced to, coupled with, or conservated over an aggregate. )
I am a white dude. Critical theory teaches that any good thing I have was obtained by false premises in ancient times on my behalf by magic workers.
Rituals of destruction
Because of this, Communism predicts that if you destroy a good thing associated with an oppressor, it automagically helps out one or more victims somewhere.
Communism also predicts that if oppressed hard enough, oppressed rise up and over throw the oppressors.
Communists also understand that desperate people are more easily motivated to turn to communists for leadership magic with which to fix problems.
All of these are reasons rooted in magical thinking for communists to willy nilly proceed with destruction magic everywhere. Furthermore, communist prediction of evil leadership, primes them to accept evil from their leaders in an effort to have their own leadership magic to offset the leadership magic that ‘oppressors’ ‘have’. This means that opportunistic assholes seek out leadership positions among communists, because they will have greater license to get their own jollies by hurting people.
There is a systemic hazard wherever communists are employed. If you employ them to take care of your cows, they dislike you for having the money to pay them, and your having cows is a crime against them. Which thereby makes you an oppressor. They think that killing your cattle is productive, and a righting of wrongs. You have to make it worth their while not to kill your cows.
Communist green and environmental politics? The analysis is not quick to reiterate, but the destruction is to the most fundamental elements of agricultural and economic efficiency, and thereby causes greater poverty and want. Public education? If it were not deliberate sabotage, they would accidently miss opportunities to cause harm and suffering at least sometimes. Welfare? Law enforcement? Employment law and corporate law? Everywhere communists get the upper hand destruction follows. Therefore destruction must be the desired result, or it would not be so consistent.
There are several positions among those who have not made themselves communist by practicing those specific magical ideas:
One is to be willing to murder communists, but also sees the murder as in itself a good. This magical thinking about destruction results in them turning everything they touch into shit.
Valuing the innate dignity of humans turns out to be fundamental to preserving value, and aggregating much wealth. If you do not capriciously destroy what a human accomplishes, because you respect that human, there may be a lot of accumulated surplus, and great wealth. Murderous idiocy is almost always bad, or could be outright always bad. Whether practiced by communists or not.
A second flavor of non-communist does not buy into mass murder, and opposes mass murder, but ignores the destructive trend in communist thinking, and hence compromises with communists in destructive rituals.
There are also non-communists who actively recognize communists as crazy and evil, and refuse to participate in ritual. But, they do not confront the communists, and do not make a show about their resistance.
Now, communists cannot really be negotiated with. And they aren’t aware of their own magical thinking, and therefore can’t reason themselves out of it. They are not really willing to deliver on anything unless forced.
Trump’s success in enraging the communists may be downstream of his efforts to negotiate. He is not strictly avoiding left ideas. However, he does see them as another party. So, as a basis for negotiation, he does not concede that any of their ideas are a good thing he would do anyway for free. To participate in any one ritual, he wants a price paid to his faction. And that price must be paid out of the communist ‘budget’ for rituals of destruction. This had the consequence of limiting the effect of rituals passing through the US government. Which in theory made it possible that the American population could get ahead of the destruction done by the communists, or for the communists to fall far behind.
Was Trump a perfect instrument of this? No. He was human, he thought he was negotiating and getting the communists to deliver, and also doing this on purpose might be hard.
However, so far it is the best we’ve seen.
Perhaps curing communists of this magical thinking is impossible. It may be possible for communism to mutate into a more sustainable religion, not my call. Evangelizing individual communists should also be possible.
It should not be impossible to stop them indoctrinating new generations. As a starting measure, if we do not grant their positions the superiority they demand be granted, if we force them to prove their destruction magic can do anything more than destruction, it might slow them enough for us to rebuild civilization and stop the infection of new generations and new structures.
Until someone comes up with a better method.











































































































