
I was going to write about the power of love. Mostly because I’m realizing the depths of depression I’d fallen into and the kittens are bringing us back to life. Little Circe, particularly, really loves her daddy and it’s healing his heart.
BUT– But lately I’m running into the narrative on Jews that is really just anti-antisemitism in glad rags. “All Jews are commies, destroying western civ. Why should we support their war.”
It’s…. interesting, shall we say? Because in the end, it comes down to “we support their war because we’re next on the Hamass menu, regardless.” But a lot of this is, bizarrely, taking organizations like ADL and claiming it speaks for all Jews, and therefore…. Which is like La Raza, or the more deranged (yes, they exist, they’re just small) Portuguese orgs in the US speaking for me. They don’t, just because I come from a vaguely allied culture, if you were wondering. I don’t think that Latin culture is superior to all others, or that the West of the US was stolen from us, and I’m not, of course, a Marxist.
I do have some insight, coming from having acculturated to the US as an adult though. Sometimes I wonder if that’s why I seem to be the only person, even among the writers and artists, who was aware of the political color bar, and what you had to do to succeed, and how you could get cancelled on suspicion of not singing fully in the progressive choir, even back in the eighties and nineties.
It was plain as the nose on my face, to me. Perhaps this was because in Portugal, by the time I hit my teen years, that political color bar was drawn in bright red and the penalties were also very obvious. The fact that some teachers spelled it out, by telling me outright if I wanted to have an A and get into college I’d best get with the program, probably didn’t hurt.
But I could see it even as an exchange student in the early 80s. It was “subtle” in a way, but you could see it. Say something outside the leftist media narrative, and everyone in the room looked at you like you were an idiot. And then it would start circulating how very not smart you were, and how you might be a little nuts. From there to social pariah was a step, though the odder and less sensitive to others’ responses might not get it and just think it’s an unfriendly group or whatever.
Note later, when I was involved in Mensa, a society that is entered by showing proof of IQ, the same mechanic applied. Open your mouth with a non-approved non-leftist narrative, and you “weren’t very bright” at best, and were a potential terrorist/racist/sexist/homophobe at worst.
The line was very clear to me, as was the assumption: All smart people; all educated and well informed people were leftist. Therefore, if you didn’t want to be judged as one of those stupid hicks and uneducated and maybe with a screw loose, you’d repeat whatever. And yeah, a lot of times, you’d end up being more left than you’d otherwise have been, because — look up cults — there is a mechanic to repeating what you don’t believe that’s used in indoctrination.
By this mechanic, most of the US upper class by the 40s (if you believe bios, and also Heinlein’s opinion) had essentially become Marxists, though unaware of it themselves. It was a function of what books were published, what programs were broadcast (radio first) and what memes were deployed. I THINK it started in the colleges, probably around and just after WWI. By WWII the only fight was German Marxists or Russian Marxists. And because of FDR the overclass went all in on the Russian side. (It might have been for the best, too, who knows? I just wish they’d woken up earlier.)
Note this was completely invisible to people who hadn’t come from another culture, be it immigrants or “working class/under class who made good.”
Leftism was a positional good. It’s actually been interesting and surprising how fast that’s falling apart since 16. It’s partly the fact that leftism is no longer holding it together to the extent of sounding even vaguely sane. And partly the fact that the masks have all come off, and the mechanic become incredibly obvious. Partly because we have access to the media of other places, times, and un-gate-kept media too.
I’m hoping this breaks both the immigrant comes in and becomes hard left, and the “lower class who makes good” becomes hard left. Because if you think about it, that’s been true for a long time. And it’s a poison pill. We all want our kids to do well/acculturate. But that means we lose them to Marxism because they want to fit in with their new circumstances. It’s been a meme in the culture forever, and yet people don’t seem to GET it. Not really get it. Makes me feel like the man with one eye.
But I never expected this effect to be held PARTICULARLY against the Jews. It’s all immigrant groups who came in during or after the 20th century. All of them. I always cringe at “oh, Hispanics are hard working, family oriented. They’ll be right wing.” No. they won’t. Because leftism is a positional good. And they want to fit in and sound high class. The effect is so strong that third generation of families escaping Communists: Russians, Chinese, Cubans, are often hard left. (And even the ones who think they aren’t, buy into a lot of the bullsh*t.) The only defense seems to be a strong religion. Hence Muslim immigrants aren’t becoming hard left, though their political culture often allies them with the Marxists. But that’s because their culture is their religion and they tend to stick in tight communities that all police each other on religion.
No, not like Jews or Catholics. Walk away from that religion, and your parents might stop talking to you. They are, however, highly unlikely to slit your throat. So, Italians, Hispanics, etc, all become Marxists to fit in. Yes, so do the Jews. Arguably some of them were Marxist (both kinds, though Jews will read danger when it almost kills them (takes a while) and soured on the German model really quickly) when they came here, because they were European upper class “d’industrie” not of birth, but those lines also blurred because noblemen like money, etc.
All of these 20th century and later immigrants, as well as the organizations that cater to them are all hard left. It’s not a coincidence. It’s because integrating in the culture involved becoming increasingly harder left. Unless you were stubborn enough that what you said out of your mouth didn’t taint your mind (grins in being me) and/or so religious that you wouldn’t go over. (Some Christians were protected, yes, but often not their kids.) It’s one of the risks of massive and uncontrolled immigration. Though to be fair, in the Jewish case, there wasn’t much they could do. They were genuine refugees and terrified. Which made their assimilation more so.
Look, we have a lot of work to do healing our culture. But the bullshit was already in our culture that pushed these people left. It’s nothing inherent in Jewishness, except the twin desire for safety and being accepted to the extent those operate. (Yes, there’s also separatedness, but that is driven from the inside only to the extent that Jews stay religious.)
I was going to paste a screen cap of a comment on Wretchard’s FB page that used ALL the talking points, about how this guy would support Israel, but frankly the Jews, as exemplified by ADL and Soros were responsible for anti-white, anti-Christian, anti-western initiatives, so let them burn, etc.
I decided not to give the asshole screen space, besides the fact I want to set him on fire.
First, Soros maybe was once upon a time a Jewish boy. Maybe. I honestly don’t know how religious his family was originally or if they tried, but he reminisces mistily about selling out other Jews for profit as a young teen. He’s evil, but he’s not Jewish in the religious sense. He might be an “Ethnic Jew” but so are a lot of people. Due to the fact that Jews are not a collective entity with a shared brain, it means nothing for Jews or Israel as a whole.
The ADL is now just a leftist organization. Yes, sure, Jews work for it. Again, leftism is/was until very recently a positional good. And? Other large organizations, including the ACLU that started as non leftist have all become screamingly leftist. This has nothing to do with Jews, and everything to do with “Our culture was already very infected when most Jews immigrated which led to all sorts of pathologies.”
“But Jews have all the power, reeeeee.” Jews in general do well, particularly when semi-assimilated. I have friends who believe it is the effect of generations selecting for who does best at professions that are mostly intellectual and portable. And they might be right. I’d like to point out though, that I think it’s also FEAR. Converso families in Portugal tend to do very well, because there is safety in wealth and position, and family trauma tends to echo through generations. That thing about culture persisting beyond genes.
Take it from the neurotic who managed to stay employed in trad pub for 30 some books, when the average career was 2 when she came in. Scrambling on your torn fingernails out of utter terror can give you a lot of lift.
So, yeah, Jews are more visible than other minorities, in some ways. Some. Though I’ll also point out a lot of people assume we’re Jewish because Biblical names and last name that sounds German (It’s actually British from the border with Wales, originally, but hey. Dan does have a ton of German, via an Amish Great grandmother.) I’ve seen this happen more than once. Prominent person in entertainment or arts, German last name, the finger pointing begins, and then you find they’re Lutheran or Catholic. (Though usually background only.) Bah.
The point here is, yeah, a lot of Jews are leftist. They also suffer from targeting issues. To understand why you need to understand that generational trauma, again. There was a post recently on how the Jewish community as a whole kept identifying Christians as the enemy, instead of the left. That’s partly because they assimilated into the left for safety, and partly because they’re hearing the words not the actions. Yes, it’s stupid. They’re not the only ones making that mistake.
This also goes to “but they exaggerate their victimhood.” Bitch, if you were retraumatized through history every few generations, and always hit when you felt safe, victimhood would also be at the center of your identity. That it is a belligerent victimhood is probably to the good. It’s how Jews survive. That it makes them then try to help everyone who proclaims himself a victim…. well, oy vey iz mir gevalt!
Though the last month and change has made a lot wake up to how they’re being used.
There is a wakening set in motion in 2020 that went further with October 7th, and a lot of masks have come off. We’re seeing a massive realignment across the lines, and not just for Jews. But it will take time, and the results might surprise even you. But these things are always slower than you think in working through.
Right now everyone is still in shock from 2020 and the masks coming off, and stumbling around punch drunk.
None of which has anything to do with the fight between Israel and Hamass. First what Hamass (the Pork Loin Brigades) did was true savagery and horror, a declaration of war not on Jews, but on all of civilization. Their doing what they did and broadcasting it amounted to “We will subdue you with violence and evil, till you bow to us.” The answer to that is always not only no but hell no, preferably with missiles, if you want to keep any civilization and decency.
Second, it’s purely in our best interests. If you think allowing Hamass to do this to Israel and destroy it utterly — which will happen if there’s a cease fire with no surrender first! — won’t result in their trying the same in our lands, you’re out of your mind. And while I don’t think they’d succeed in America, looking at Europe makes me doubtful they wouldn’t succeed there. At least enough to make the rest of the world hazardous to America.
Third, the axis of evil, totalitarian regimes is real. And it doesn’t include Israel. Which is why our evil would be totalitarians much love China, and only reluctantly pay Israel lip-service and play f*ck f*ck games on aid. BTW all the totalitarians are in major economic and other trouble. Part of their recent belligerence is an attempt to save themselves. And like our home grown Bidenmites, the more they try to flail around and fix things, the deeper they dig.
It is in the best interest of CIVILIZATION to back Israel. Because Hamass is the opposite of civilization. And will take us all down given a choice.
As for the anti-Semites…. they’ll always be with us, I guess. However, before you buy their idiocy, do pay attention to the logic and how this affects other groups.
There is a concerted propaganda effect going on to leave Israel out in the cold. And for various reasons, the right always falls for this. ALWAYS. The right in the US are so susceptible to propaganda it’s a miracle we survive at all.
Again, as yesterday, don’t echo malicious propaganda, and do make an effort to identify what is propaganda and aimed at winning by other means the war started with savagery and horrible crimes against civilians.
Be not afraid and be not stupid. Stay safe out there.







































































































