The problem with totalitarian states is a problem of information, or lack thereof. No one wants to tell the boss that things didn’t turn out the way he planned. And there’s a hierarchy of bosses before the ultimate boss. At each level, the information is corrupted.
Suppose that you manage a factory making boots for the army. You were asked to make 4000 pairs of boots, but you only managed ten, because the leather for the boots never got to you. When the big boss asks for the boots, of course you tell him it’s on the way, the because you know the leather providers lied and said they got it to you. The guy in charge of transport, in turn, will tell his boss the trucks are fueled up and full of boots. The fact is no only doesn’t he have boots, but also no fuel and possibly no trucks.
This is why totalitarian regimes make wrong decisions and why they lose wars. Also why they’re absolutely convinced they’re the strongest, etc. until they lose.
Now I’m going to blow your mind: this is not exclusive to totalitarian states. It’s in fact endemic in any system where truth imposed from above and no redemption is possible. In fact, most centralized organizations of a certain size, with no countervailing culture.
You know all the chest beating “In this company there’s no room for failure?” That’s a company that will fail, because people working for it can’t afford to.
If your company — say — expects the editor to know exactly how many copies a book will sell, in a system that neither surveys the market nor knows how to market, the editor will pull numbers from ass, control as much as he can to make sure it sells the right number, and — if needed — pull the book out of print if it’s going to sell too much. Because no failure allowed and estimating too few sales is as bad as estimating too many. (True story, not me, but someone had a book that was becoming an unexpected runaway bestseller pulled out of print after a week. And the editor refused to put it back in print.)
I’m sure there are a ton of other examples, from huge corporations, where people are taught that they need to set goals and be inflexible, and that there is no failure, etc.
However, the most obvious examples for this are our media, our intelligence agencies, our institutions that are supposed to know what people think and want and how they are coping with current issues.
I was reminded of this today when I accidentally tripped on an article where the writer was utterly baffled all surveys claimed that religion and religiosity are in sharp decline in the US and yet the Bible is hitting new numbers in sales and the top podcast is a Rosary in a Year podcast.
I mean, I don’t know about you, but I absolutely can square that circle. It’s not even difficult. If the surveys aren’t outright fabrications — a big if these days — chances are that what was asked as if they were members of a church. With the mainstream churches, without exceptions, tilting more and more into conformity with the leftist establishment, a lot of people who are very serious about their religion are finding it hard to attend a church or admit they belong to an organized church.
Of course, the left who are most of the people commissioning these surveys, wouldn’t even understand this concept, because in their minds “left” is just mainstream, and churches that are leftist should therefore be the most popular. If people aren’t attending them, it must mean they’re no longer believers.
Or alternately they asked people who don’t trust the person asking the questions, and who would be destroyed if their colleagues knew they were religious.
Part of the problem, of course, is that the information/culture/industrial complex is running the Marxist script according to which the smarter and more “advanced” you get the less religious. And every bit of information they get must fit into the matrix or be disregarded.
Because, well, failure is not an option. If the Marxist assumptions are wrong, their whole world collapses, because they’ve been interpreting everything through the Marxist assumptions.
The other part of the problem is that their cultural branches continually manufacture pseudo-knowledge, which adds up to a picture of the world that has nothing to do with reality, but does so by being so pervasive, so unified and so inescapable, that it triggers our subconscious impression of what’s real.
What do I mean? Well, it turns out that things like TV and movies can trick the back of our brain into thinking what we watched is real. It won’t stand up to examination, but it is never examined. Our brain doesn’t actually have a defense against seeing things that look realistic but aren’t real. This wasn’t a thing in our evolution.
So, people assume something like 25% of people are gay, and 50% of people are black, and probably at this point that something like another 25% are transgender. The numbers are, of course, nowhere close to that. Not even vaguely.
BUT the system of information is corrupted and that feeds more corruption.
About five years ago I stopped watching British mysteries. Understand that, even though some series bothered me with political insanity, most of them didn’t, and it was my escape. And then I realized that every couple shown in every series, including those set in the 30s was a bi-racial couple. Why? I don’t know. I asked friends from England if this was realistic and the answer was ‘lol, no.’
And I couldn’t watch it. Because the fact EVERY SINGLE couple was bi-racial obtruded to such a level I couldn’t suspend disbelief.
And then recently, I started seeing this in American movies. Just… all of a sudden every couple is bi-racial, unless they’re both some non-white variety. These are stories set in small towns in areas of America I know d*mn well — having been there — are 90% white.
Yes, this means I rant at the TV and my husband tells me to shush, but seriously!
I have no problem with bi-racial marriage. By the crazy leftist definition I’m in one, though it’s really hard to figure out which of us is what race, and you have to squint and go with the 10% rule. (Like most Americans, we’re just shades of beige.) And I seem to have an unusual number of friends who married different races. Mostly I think because I’m part of a group where we couldn’t care less for “race” but care for individuals. And being Odds we have enough trouble finding people we get along with without caring about skin color or “ethnic” features.
However, I know d*mn well that day to day, out there, bi-racial couples aren’t that common. Most people are or appear to be “standard white” (see we aren’t at home to the one drop theory in this case. It’s visual identification, and for that most people are “white” ranging from pale blond to tanned Mediterranean.) Then there are some obviously Hispanic couples, some Indians, and depending on where you are, a lot of black couples, but nowhere near as many as white-white couples. Bi-racial couples aren’t rare enough that people turn to look, but they also aren’t anywhere close to the rule.
I have nothing against the occasional ethnic or bi-racial couple in a movie. I’m not even going to stand here and go “Well, statistically it’s 15%” or whatever (For one, statistics are unreliable, because they depend on self-identification, which mostly depends on the one drop rule.) If 2/3 of the couples are white, and the 1/3 is mixed, ethnic, whatever? That won’t feel jarring. Heck, 50/50 wouldn’t feel jarring. It’s when you start noticing it’s something like 90% mixed and you don’t see a single white-white couple. And you start going “What reality are these people living in?”
The reality they’re living in is one in which they think black and white are 50/50 and then the other ethnicities are 30% (yes, I know, but Math is racist. You know that.) And everyone is isolated and belongs to this group and hates everyone else.
In their befuddled little minds — ask them. They’ll rant about the global South and how white people are going extinct. It’s stupid stuff, but you see, they give incentives for claiming to be a minority, and never notice people change IDENTIFICATION not ethnicity — they’re easing the extincting of you those evil Westerners by promoting bi-racial marriage and “erasing whiteness.” This in turn will bring about magical califragilistic communist Utopia.
Anyway, the only way to make sense of this is to get into the minds of these people, and it’s almost impossible to do so, because there’s failures of information, at every level.
Take for instance the fact the head of every police department is a woman and has been for at least the last 30 years, in every TV show and movie. (Though they used to also allow black men.) If you believe that, you’re going to think that when this doesn’t happen people are being “intentionally held back” and need DEI. And then…. And then things like LA happen. Because every time you promote or select based on any characteristic but competence, you are degrading competence and end up with mediocrity.
It basically amounts to “delusion on delusion on delusion.” And it’s impossible to figure it out completely, even if you make guesses.
This is to say, as a lot of people become redpilled, don’t assume they’re faking it. A lot of them really were lost in a morass of bad information and bad first principles to which to interpret the information.
The thing is that one event that is shocking enough can wake people from this type of thing. (It’s how you deprogram cult members.) And Trump’s election was a very shocking event for them. They thought they had won full control of the country forever.
So some of the newly red-pilled might be completely sincere. (Though probably not the ones who claim not to have known Biden had dementia. At least not those that had any contact with him.)
The other thing is: you don’t have to mimic their errors in thought. You don’t have to believe their TV shows and run around with your head on fire saying the “white race is going extinct.” (For one, you’d have to define white race. Also, the “white race” has absorbed so many things considered “not white” and yet it’s still here. Chill.) You don’t have to listen to their designated ethic virtue-bearer talk about how he hates all whites and believe this is true of your neighbor who tans a bit.
And you certainly don’t have to believe no one is religious anymore. Or that America has changed out of all recognition. Or that people don’t want to work anymore. Or whatever is being pushed by the crazy media, at the top of the pile of distortions and lies.
As the election showed, this country is nowhere near dead, and mostly Americans are Americans. (With some cities entirely taken over by invaders. Probably. Only I haven’t been there.)
No, you can’t find anything about the country as a whole and be sure it’s true. All of the information streams are corrupted. But there are clues.
I knew that the left wasn’t fully in control or even close to in control when Let’s Go Brandon went viral and was everywhere. I knew the economy sucked because I have a lot of friends in all types of retail. And also because I saw the prices in the supermarket. I knew the real state of people’s satisfaction with the Bidentia by listening to people at the supermarket. (I listen to strangers’ conversations. I’m a writer. We have no shame.)
This is again to say “Get out and touch grass.” Or better yet, look around at reality, listen to people not in your immediate circle. Look at the subtle signs the left is in real trouble. (The right can boycott brands into submission is one of those. The opposite isn’t true. They’re loud but not many.)
Always look behind the ideas and “facts” being dished out by the media and experts. Sure, they’ll call you a conspiracy theorist, but these days it’s just what they call people not taken in by the psy-ops. And there are more and more of us every day.
Because the “facts” the left is dishing out just don’t add up. They’re as phony as wooden nickels and you’d have to be a fool to believe them.
Or foreigners. As I found out in October, in Europe they tend to believe everything they see in our media. Which means Americans on average are part of a shootout a day, we’re all in mixed race marriages, and all our men are stupid and all our women brilliant.
Let them fool themselves. It’s dangerous enough to have them running around in an illusion.
We don’t have to join them.