
So, I realize it’s been a long long time. Mostly because I ran into a spate of books where I couldn’t find the book OR any other book by the writer or in the series, either in ebook or paper. So, I got discouraged and then … well, mom’s death (I’m still working through that. There are days) and the desensitization therapy, and you know stupid thyroid tricks, and stuff, and I got really out of the groove.
So, if you don’t remember what this is about: this is the explanation. And these are the past reviews 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6.
And if for some reason after reading my review (or before) you want to read it, it’s available as an ebook here: Donovan’s Brain by Curt Siodomak
First the obligatory bio (I find so much stuff in these things.)
Writer and Director. Nationality: American. Born: Kurt Siodmak in Dresden, Germany, 10 August 1902; brother of the director Robert Siodmak. Education: Attended the University of Zurich, Ph.D. 1927. Family: Married Henrietta de Perrot, 1931, one son. Career: Reporter, freelance writer, and railway engineer; 1929—first film as writer, People on Sunday; 1930—first novel published; 1934–37—writer for Gaumont-British; 1937—moved to the United States, and writer for Paramount, 1938–40, and Universal, 1940–46; 1951—first film as director, Bride of the Gorilla; 1952—formed production company with Ivan Tors.
I knew of course from the name that Siodmak was German in origin, obviously. but I didn’t know he was actually born in Germany. Nor that he only moved to the US as an adult. Every time I start feeling like the lone ranger, I run into another science fiction author who came from elsewhere altogether.
I had no idea at all he was also a director, and I know at least one of my commenters is going to yell at me for saying this but I never saw any of his books, nor do the titles ring any bells. (But I’m not a great movie person. In fact, I might be the opposite of a movie person, since I will do every other form of entertainment, including but not limited to tiddly winks than watching a movie. I usually passive watch movies, like people inhale passive smoke. Dan watches the movies, and I, being a cat, have to look up at the images now and then, while I follow the sound.)
Donovan’s Brain was published in 1942. Perhaps some of the aspects of the writing are influenced by WWII, which had to be hard to cope with, particularly for a German author in America.
Or maybe I’m refining too much on it. Or perhaps the feeling of dread and horror that filled me reading the book last night has more to do with the fact I was feeling very ill, (I have the going around thing) and read because I couldn’t sleep, I don’t know.
The book filled me with dread and depression, almost from the beginning. It is the story of Doctor Patrick Cory who is doing experiments to find out if he can keep a brain alive and improve it.
I hated the character from the moment he gains a very sick cappuchin monkey’s trust then kills him. Look, I don’t know what the author was trying to convey. And I am not a bleeding heart who is against all animal experimentation. I’m not even against primate experimentation. I recognize that things have to be tried and that we have the medical science we have thanks to experiments on animals. BUT — but — this is a very personal and visceral thing. I’d have been fine if he’d just met the animal, grabbed it and killed it while it struggled. Mind you, for a first chapter it would still be off putting. BUT not the absolute turn off of taming the animal and nurturing him, then cuddling him and killing him as he falls asleep. To me that type of thing is an absolute betrayal of trust and revolts me. Yes, euthanasia. Note, please that none of our cats go in till they’re in obvious and unbearable pain the painkillers can’t touch. And then only because I know they don’t understand their suffering. It’s not something I can explain to them. And I’m certainly not going to befriend a random sick animal and then kill him.
Sure, he wants to use the monkey’s brain to test his theories, fine. I suppose the first chapter is supposed to show us he’ll go to any lengths to do his experiments. Ah, ah ruthless, etc. I’m not sure I’m reading it properly, but if I were writing this, and wrote it that way, it would be because I meant to make this guy repulsive.
The fact that his relationship with his wife seems to be that he exploits his wife, and doesn’t really try to have a relationship with her, makes me actively dislike him even more. (And also the ninny who puts up with that treatment.)
After this there is a plane crash and somehow the doctor ends up being first responder. one of the men is lethally injured, but not dead so he kills him by removing his brain and hooking him up to his apparatus.
After that, the book rapidly devolves into a horror novel, specifically a possession novel. He tries to communicate with the brain (which is the brain of a rich man who has done some shady things) and then somehow manages to establish a telepathic connection, through which the brain ends up controlling the scientist.
They (the brain possessing the body) kill someone, and then just before he kills his wife, the despised/ignored assistant he left behind kills the brain (and himself in the process.)
The scientist then has some kind of breakdown, and ends up in the hospital, but ends up rewarded with a nice position and home, happy end all around.
I have only two problems: First it’s a horror novel and not even, really, a science fiction horror novel. All the touch stones of the story are traditional, spiritual horror. I don’t like horror, and of all horror that makes me recoil possession is absolutely the worst.
And yeah, okay, I took had a character get his mind highjacked. I’ll just say neither the character being possessed nor the possessor were half as repulsive as this pair.
The second is that the main character didn’t die screaming, with his death detailed in excruciating and loving exactness on the page. Because by halfway through the book, I hated him with the fire of a thousand suns.
I think in the end the truth is that Siodmak (whose name drove me nuts as a little dyslexic girl in Portugal, since I confused him with Simak and no, no, no.) to my mind — and this is entirely my opinion — might have come to the US; he might even have naturalized, but in the end his mental map was that of an early 20th century — and to an extent even now — European. For a book to be good almost every personality in it must be repulsive and make the author want to drown them in a vat of lake water filled with eels.
Maybe that’s just my opinion and maybe that is also a function of my being sick and feeling out of sorts, who knows.
Interestingly, though, though I remember reading Siodmak, I don’t remember a single one of his books, and I’m almost sure I either never read Donovan’s Brain before, or gave up on it after a couple of chapters.
Anyway, that’s done. Next up, secured at great expense (used, in paper, on Amazon) Anthro, the Life Giver written by John J. Deegan.
I’ll try to get to it next week, like a normal person. If you want to follow along at home, there is ONE used copy here. And I suppose you can hit up your local used bookstores and see if they have it. (If you want to know the list I’m following, it’s here. The site will translate.)
This is the Portuguese edition of Anthro The Lifegiver is below. The Portuguese title translates to Explorers of the universe, which is pathetically generic. But considering how outre science fiction was even years later when I came along, I won’t blame them for trying to make it sound tame and reasonable.
Anyway, looking forward to it. (With my luck it will be horror again. Ah, well, it’s paper. I can always wall it if it upsets me that much.)






















































































































































































































