
Yesterday I came across a convincing slopcore — clanker music — video that posited that clankers will be used for social engineering and also that the iteration of AIs had rendered the “genius in the basement” obsolete.
It was convincing because it was almost right. ALMOST. Yes, of course that’s how the story goes. And we’ve read the story a million times so we know how it ends. Sing it with me: Every improvement can be taken to catastrophic levels. Every technology enables tyranny. We’re always done. It’s always all over.
You know, if it weren’t because I’ve seen the vaunting ambition side of this too, I’d suspect the serpent in the garden had whispered “give up and lie down at ease. It’s all over. You already lost.” (Maybe that’s what happened to all the other human species that vanished.)
However, social engineering doesn’t work. Or not the way the engineers intended. Things change, sure, but not in the direction they want.
For instance, I knew their push to turn boys into girls and girls into boys, which has gone on, non-explicitly (then explicitly and derangedly the last 15 years) for close on to 100 years had failed when we went back to our old church for a service, when we visited Colorado 3 years ago. You have to understand, this church for reasons of where it is attracts mostly professors, college-adjacent people and tech workers. So it was always a hip-ish place to be. (Not why we attended. It was 5 minutes from our house and when we first moved there, the priest was amazing.) Well, by the time we moved from Colorado we hadn’t attended there in 3 years because it had fallen off the deep end of woke and crazy. When we went back, five years later, it had swung the other way so hard I was the only woman in pants and without a veil. And the people there were the YOUNG with very young families. The place was more vibrant and full of life than it had ever been. I took it as an omen.
I was right. We’re now seeing that swing in the population in general: men who want to be men. Women who want to be women. Couples who want what their grandparents had: actual homes that are more than places to sleep, and scads of fat babies.
Did the social engineering fail? Well, yes. They intended something like Brave New World.
And that video had the key too: the AI gives you what you want, but it only takes in account the factors you give it.
Which means the genius in the basement is not obsolete. A real genius, who knows what to ask for and how to implement it is AUGMENTED.
Which…. uh…. While I’m thinking about it, and knowing this lot, I’ll just say before you play Manuel Garcia O’Kelly, let alone Bernardo de la Paz to your own Mycroft, kindly to make sure the AI isn’t phoning home or to the authorities. (Warden boys always listening.) So a private instance, and again, if basing it on Chinese models, make sure they don’t call home. Husband (not doing that, just bog standard coding in his spare time) caught it trying to call home, long after he thought he’d extirpated all such code.
The point is the reason social engineering never works is that humans never take all the factors into account. It’s not actually possible. And AI is an instrument, not a magic genii.
Now does it have downsides and can it hurt us? EVERYTHING can hurt us. Those flaked stone hand axes were used to kill humans, not just game, you know?
One of the subtle downsides of AI: I’ve been– slightly depressed. (Look, no serial killer stories, I pulled up above that. But I’m on a steady diet of Jane Austen. And writing takes forever, posts and fiction, because concentration is shot.) Mostly I think grief, though there’s something physical going on that is very mildly upper respiratory and heavily no appetite/tired all the time. (I assure you I’ll go bug my doctor next week, if it goes on.) So I started using a harmless little aid: this book has a million side characters, and an effect when I’m depressed is that I don’t remember where I left “3rd speaking part from the right” last, or their description. So I’ve been feeding what I have as I have, then asking “Please tell me what does the fourth erring magician look like? What’s his line name again?” And getting it.
Harmless, right? Like a prompter.
What I’ve found is that it contributes to keep me from immersing fully, and makes it harder to take the story seriously. So, it’s stopping today. BUT I suspect there are about a million of those little, hidden flytraps lying about as one changes one’s process. And that it’s worse for those heavily using AI.
As always? It exacts a price. Not just from the individual. We’re going to lose what would otherwise be great coders and amazing writers. So? I won’t say if they could be destroyed by AI they should be. As you know, I don’t like waste no matter the cause.
What I will say is that this is is inevitable. Every change, good or bad exacts a toll. It’s part of living in this fallen world and being human and fallible.
But every change — even bad ones — bring opportunities as well. And some clever, hard working, annoying, fractious apes will take advantage of those. Every time.
Which is why the tombstone for the human race will remain above an empty grave.
And yeah, changes of other type too.
But you need to not lie down and die. It’s easier, yes, but it also has no opportunities whatsoever.
Be ready to build over, build under, build around. Rumors of our demise have been greatly exaggerated. Barring the Sweet Meteor of Doom they’ll probably continue to be so.
Which is why the Slopcore — a name adopted as a raised middle finger at those who call all AI music slop, without realizing it’s its own form of art — will continue till morale improves. Every Friday. Same bat channel. Same bat-sh*t crazy writer. Still ticking.
The slopcore will be very HFY. And I hope you enjoy it. (And as for certain writers who AI modify and animate pictures of their young selves? I have no opinion of them! Honestly, the nerve! … but it is nice to remember one was young and not wholly unattractive once upon a time.)