
Sometimes while I’m here, in the evening chair, in the family room, writing my blog post and doing instapundit, my husband watches a movie. Ranging on what the movie is, this can range from distracting because I watch it or parts of it, to infuriating.
Elysium was the second kind. in fact, it was so bad that about halfway through I went upstairs to bed because otherwise I was going to just start screaming at the TV and not stop. The reasons were many from worldbuilding — LA looks like the bad parts of Mexico city, there’s nuns who raise orphans who aren’t orphans, everyone speaks Spanish, except the designated oppressors who speak Africans or English with a South African accent, and who also inexplicably seem to always know where the hero is, or something.
ANYWAY, moving right along…..
Perhaps the thing that infuriated me most was the harping on the “overpopulation” and how there are so many of us that we’re destroying the planet (and that’s why the rich moved to a space habitat.)
It infuriated me for several reasons:
First, even demographers are finally talking about “catastrophic population crash” taking overpopulation as gospel is insane. Yes, I know the movie was done a few years ago — I don’t know how many and I’m too lazy to look it up — but even then they should have had an inkling of a glimmer of a thought that perhaps the “population bomb” wasn’t precisely coming true. For one, because all the predictions Ehrlich ever made about it (or anything else) failed. In fact, a good way to predict the future is to look at whatever Paul Ehrlich says and believe the opposite. In that, he might be invaluable.
Second, Population exploding to the level they posited in a still recognizable future might be — for real — impossible for the simple reason that people who don’t exist can’t have kids. I note they had some inkling they weren’t seeing this gigantic population explosion around them, hence why everyone in the overgrown LA favela spoke Spanish. Also probably the reason for the nuns. I didn’t understand the Spanish (I could have, but would have to slow it way down) and they didn’t translate it in subtitles, but I wonder if the nuns were there to give the idea of those horrible Catholics who reproduce like rabbits. At any rate, not only is this idea that Spanish speakers (Or Arabic speakers, or–) are reproducing like rabbits and that if they keep it up they’ll destroy the world one of the oldest lies of eugenics, but the premise is also almost certainly completely wrong.
It’s hard to tell, because no one does accurate numbers not even us, and we’re practically autistic in our obsession with numbers, but everyone who pokes closer panics, because population does in fact seem to be falling worldwide, and people of all races and creeds are having fewer and fewer children.
Crappy cultures seem overpopulated only because they are so crappy they can’t provide even for the few young people they have.
Third – All the problems they attribute to overpopulation are not overpopulation, but the problems of crappy cultures. In the brief snatch of world-in-action, few have jobs and there is no societal trust or respect for private property. There’s nothing to an “overpopulated area” that causes that. Yes, in the seventies it was believed it was inevitable with higher population densities to get out of control crime, and lack of security and– But Rudy Giulliani and others proved it was not inevitable. It was a choice. It was Democrat culture choosing to mollycoddle criminals and punish the law abiding. Apparently the Democrats love that choice because they are making it again. But again, it has nothing to do with population density. It has to do with crappy government and crappy culture, and encouraging the worst in humans.
Just because you set the world on fire again and again and again, it doesn’t mean the world is particularly flammable, only that your beliefs make the world burn.
Now, why did the population thing get under my skin to that point? Well, mostly because it is probably the most important fight of our time.
All the problems we used to think were caused by overpopulation: the loss of wealth, the inability to feed everyone, etc. are in fact problems in low population. Because the highest resource of humanity is humans. We are clever apes, who can engineer our way into anything.
Oh, as a side note, before I go on with this, the movie made much of the fact that Elysium — the space habitat — didn’t allow the Spanish speaking, favella-dwelling poor in. This was of course evil and racist. But in fact if the culture of the poor was what was shown in the movie, the habitat couldn’t let them in. Because they’d just make it the same as they’d made of the Earth, and nothing would be improved. So this whole thing was an argument from pointless and counterproductive compassion.
But to return to population and our real issue, which is a lack of people. And since people create resources, by finding them or producing them, a lack of resources with it. The economy doesn’t work when the next generation is markedly smaller and the one after that even smaller than that.
There is also a psychological side. Humans work for the future. And the future of humans is other humans. Part of the reason socialism kills slowly is that the generations rely on the state, not each other, and while young people think “why bother” and don’t have kids, but kids are needed for the state to provide for the old, and more importantly, to give adults a sense of the future.
I think if we survive this bottle neck, we’re going to find that our subconscious has a need for a certain number of kids just around in the environment, kind of like I found out through the lockdown that I needed to see strangers. That the one day a week Dan and I drove around and did museums/zoo/went to dinner with friends made a huge difference and foregoing it made me spiral down into unending, bottomless depression, because something in the ape brain, something inarticulate and possibly inarticulable (Pshaw, totally a word) made it so I had to see a certain number of strangers every so often or I’d think that I was alone in the ice floe, left to die, or something.
In the same way, I think we’re going to find we need to see a certain number of young people/children. And we need to live with/around a certain number of young people and children.
If you think of when our instincts were set and what child mortality was set, I suspect that number is fairly high.
And this morning, while talking to an online friend about cats and why they are so necessary to so many of us, and why their deaths hit us so hard, I realized that’s an indicator.
It’s not disputed that cats have kind of hacked us into taking care of them — or we hacked them — by changing their features and sounds so that they mimic the look and feel of an infant to our back-brain.
Cats have always been with us, and some number of us always found them irresistible. But it’s also undeniable that their popularity is growing all over, and that people not only have larger numbers of cats, but treat the cats increasingly like children and get more and more attached to them.
I realized to my discomfort sometime last year that I need young cats around to feel even vaguely optimistic, in fact.
Well, think about it, in the times when our back brain was programmed, I’d be, if not dead then the tribe matriarch, whose main value would be to mind the kids while the parents hunted and gathered and to impart to them my dubious wisdom.
So I probably need sixteen or seventeen kids around all the time, most of them the toddling ages — too old to be carried by mommy while gathering too young to help and not run away.
The cats are perfect for this. And if it were just me, since I don’t want to open a daycare, they’re the perfect hack. And I’m from one of those weird families that always adored cats. (Also a consistently relatively low fertility family, which might tie in.)
But more and more of humanity’s sanity might be riding on their fuzzy butts. And no matter if Engineer-Indy is engineer, cats are not the future of humanity.
We’re in deep, deep trouble. And evil pieces of propaganda blaming more humans for all ills possible — but mostly imaginary — just push us deeper into trouble.
Maybe it’s time our overculture got — or was given — a clue, and stopped killing us softly with their bullshit.





























































































































































