*Look, before I start this post I HAVE TO brag. Which is kind of like having to bake, with fewer pans and flour. No shade on Mark S. who still wrote my favorite Amazon review, but this one…. this one is not a good review. It’s the review I’d have dreamed of if I knew this was possible! REVIEW OF SARAH HOYT’S NO MAN’S LAND. I’m not sure how I deserved this. I’m sure I’m not worthy, and all I can say is “aye, aye, captain. Working on Orphans of the Stars as much and as fast as I can” -SAH*
Vibing History

There are things I seem to have been appointed to scream out in the desert (by whom is a good question. Perhaps a superior power. Perhaps my subconscious. I don’t care. Whatever it is is much smarter than my conscious mind and seems to come to accurate conclusions on insufficient data, so I listen.)
So I’ve spent my time screaming what I think is obvious in the face of overwhelming opposition. Though some of them the rest of the world seems to be coming around on. One of those is “The population is NOT exploding. Paul Ehrlich was wrong on this too, as on everything else. What we have are incentives to over report. The real danger is population dearth. The only real wealth is human beings and human minds.”
But there are others. Oh there are others, and some of these I scream in the face of my own unalterable pessimism. And the thing is, although the pessimism shouts back that all is doomed, so far the optimism has been correct. Whether I’m like the man falling from a high building, passing the fifth floor window and going “So far so good.”is way way above my paygrade. And I likely won’t find out in my lifetime, even if I live another 40 years, which is unlikely but possible.
Because what I’m saying is not that the fight is DONE and everything will be rainbows and flowers from here on. That has never happened in the history of humanity and never will. Humanity is forever on the edge of a precipice. All we can do is catalogue the good, the bad, and hope that our descendants keep good trends going or combat the bad.
However, these my inner voice thinks is true:
In our current fight, we have already won. What remains is mop-up which, as we all know, is the most dangerous portion of the action, because the enemy has nothing to lose and will go all out to take even one of us.
We — potentially, there’s a couple of big inflection points ahead — stand on the very edge of a mountain of achievement that will take us to the stars, make us a multi-planet species and make our descendants healthy and wealthy beyond the dreams of avarice. Which in turn will create more achievement, because that’s how it works. (And no, it won’t be paradise. No paradise in this sorry world where world means this universe.)
Everything is upgef*cket and will need to be rebuilt in the next 20 years. Everything: Physical infrastructure, education, institutions, our transmission of our civic culture, the rebuilding of faith in our churches. AND don’t get me started on the rest of the world. We might be able to do it. I’m not sure about them.
AND the dictum meeting with even more resistance than those: Stop blaming and beating the young. And by young in this case I mean 45 and younger. Every generation complains about inheriting a broken world. They didn’t in fact inherit a broken world. Neither did we. Neither did Cain and Abel to use metaphor. The world is no more broken than it’s always been in this our vale of tears. THEY DID HOWEVER INHERIT AN EDUCATION SYSTEM AND INSTITUTIONS THAT CAN’T BE TRUSTED. NOT EVEN A LITTLE BIT.
Look, all of us, even people my age (this isn’t saying much as I came after. More on that later) were badly educated for the world as it is. This is because since the eighteenth century or so the world has been changing faster than the culture, mostly due to tech, and the whole process is accelerating.
I, for instance, took a degree in languages and literature which yes, would have given me instant entrance into a teaching profession (in Portugal) and since I’m insane and came out with seven languages and at the top of my class in most (except German, and even there I was in the top ten. I just hate German. It’s too organized for my brain.) supposing I got a personality transplant, I could have become a diplomat of some sort. (This was what mom, G-d rest her, was holding out for. It’s like she never met me. In answer to her hopes, my brother drafted a newspaper article from 2030 where I’d been declared Persona non grata in every country in the world, including Portugal.)
But the degree wasn’t actually designed for any of that. What it was designed for was to make me “an accomplished young lady” who would shine in the marriage mart. Because it was established that long ago, and universities in Portugal were very slow to change in spirit. (And yet a bunch of Marxism had crept in, mostly through literary analysis. No. It’s no more valid there than anywhere else. The people who maintain that the theory is wrong but “still valid” for this or that are actually saying “So the theory that there are cows on the moon is complete insanity, but still good for NASA mission planning.” Come again? I must be hearing wrong.)
This is normal. This is bog standard. This is what we always went through. And part of the reason when young we think the world is broken for us specifically. Because we’re young we trust what we were taught and are angry and bewildered it doesn’t match anything.
My kids generation and later (I COULD have kids who are now forty five, if I’d got started early and if my fertility were higher than that of your average rock in the desert) had a particular cross to bear though that was much worse than that.
When I said “I came after” I meant it had already started in my generation, though we had it slightly better due to societal inertia. This is good and bad. Good, because we can understand how effed up things can be. Bad because we who are now grandparent age have internalized “everyone goes through this. They just need to fight harder” and then blame the young more. Which is very very bad, because the system has corroded further since our time and because if we were ejected into a world that was fast-setting jelly holding us down, they were ejected into a world that’s quick-set cement and with fewer resources than we had because education has also decayed further. Oh, no further than that. Let me tell you as someone who taught her kids around and after school, I saw some decay in what they got, but didn’t realize how dire things were till I met their friends. (Look, my kids are genetic, compulsive over achievers and tend to associate with their like. This means I’ve met the creme de la creme of their generation at least in their circles. The depth not just of their ignorance, but what they learned that is bizarrely possibly even intentionally wrong is unfathomable. You stare into it and the abyss answers back “Wut?”)
And every one of these kids now entering middle aged is still struggling more than we did in our twenties, because all of American (and we’re still the best of the west) society has been weaponized AGAINST them. They weren’t allowed to take crappy teen jobs to build resilience AND defray their college expenses AND give them a resume. (My kids made up jobs, but it wasn’t enough. There is no such thing as a paper route at 12 anymore. There isn’t even mowing the lawns for money. There isn’t EVEN a lemonade stand, because if they catch you they’ll fine you within an inch of your life.) We treat them like lepers and blame them for what they don’t know. AND to put the cherry on the cake, the project of our (spits) “elites” for the last fifty years has been to outsource their jobs to foreigners either legal or illegal, either here or offshore, because it’s cheaper. It’s not that the kids expect to come in at middle management. It’s that there is nothing but the crappiest, most weaponized against humans jobs (Retail, now, where you don’t even know your schedule day to day but you’re still required to keep it, blindly, regardless of other commitments, even family and classes. No, it’s not just the kids whining. Ask some of the commenters who are very much adults and stuck in that how much fun it is.)
Then there is the “came after” thing. Look, I knew that I — already — didn’t have the education my dad or my brother had. And it’s not modernization, since that hadn’t hit in Portugal. I was born in sixty two at the very end. (No, not a boomer, for this and many many other reasons.) My brother is almost ten years older. My brother went through school in the same elite set of schools (his was the boy’s side) I attended later. (Mom maneuvered into it with faked addresses, etc. It was public school but it was also where most people went into college. Not a lot. It was by grades on a final, national, blind graded exam. But about 2 to 3% of our high schools made it in, compared to 0.5% of the general population.)
My brother learned Latin and (I THINK) a modicum of Greek in high school. Mathematics through Calculus. Serious physics and chemistry and all the rest. He came out of high school with an education our recent college graduates have no way of touching till maybe a Masters degree.
I came in well, he was advanced faster, so a full 10 years or more later. Latin was gone. Greek was gone. Only French was taught, we had to fight for me to get English. The rest? Cutesy things like sociology (Scientific Marxism really. Yes, Weaponized Envy Fantasies) had been brought in. The rest was still there. And I still graduated from high school with what would now be a “general knowlege” (Whatever they call those) college degree.
However, even back then, at the dawning of the eighties, I knew I’d only been educated to about my brother’s Middle School level. I KNOW. I read his books. (And tried to learn, but like all autodidacts I have holes the size of the grand canyon and don’t always know where.)
What happened? Well, I didn’t find out until I was reading a book on the “educational revolution” of the sixties, which I’d picked up at a bargain bin, because it was a couple of cents, and I read everything.
What happened was the boomers. No, not throwing shade on those of you of that generation. This was “activists” plus the bizarre idea at the time that the youth cohort would keep increasing, be a force in politics, and we should APPEASE them now, instead of making them learn and work. (You see this in Heinlein’s novels. I don’t remember in which high school students were striking for higher pay and no homework. Yes, satire, but it tells you what people at the time expected of the future.) Turns out the “Student revolts” of the sixties and seventies weren’t all anti-war or for the transmission of lice among the unwashed. They also demanded and got a watering down of the curriculum, the retiring of strict professors and well “Credentials for nothing and our degrees for a lot of money but no effort.” The truth was the colleges were, of course, cool with that. because more money, less work, more power to bureaucrats.
The “revolution” propagated downward, particularly as a lot of the graduates of those times became the teachers my generation got in middle and high school. (Which explained the plague of “Call me John. I’m just one of you. You’ll teach me more than I teach you” we started getting hit with in sixth and seventh grade, and which MULTIPLIED.)
Wait a minute, Sarah, you’ll say. You were in PORTUGAL. How did that propagate? Are you really going to ask that? For my entire life — my parents’ entire life and dad is in his late 90s — the future has come from America, and everywhere has decided whatever America did was the thing to do (all while hating America. Humans, amiright?) For illustration see covidiocy. And also foreigners tend to do it harder and more stupidly. When America Sneezes the rest of the world catches pneumonia.
So I know what it’s like to be ejected into the world half-taught. And husband and I had to fight his parents to get them to understand the “get a job, be loyal, they’ll be loyal in return and you’re set for life.” We came into the work force in 1980. Most people got jobs after a long period of working crappy temporary jobs. Thing is there were A LOT of temporary jobs (this was largely before outsourcing, so that was the hack to exploit people at lower wages.) And retail was not scheduled “at need” by computers, so you got your schedule a week or two even ahead. Pay was crappy, but the jobs were predictable. You could navigate two or — when I was in retail I had a friend who did this and so did her husband. For extra difficulty they also coordinated it so that one of them was always home with the baby at any given time. Heroes, both, but this isn’t even possible now. Now it would take a daily miracle — three retail jobs.
On top of that these people, adult citizens, who vote, were ejected into the world with absolutely no understanding of fundamental realities of life, like biology, history and economics.
“But they could learn” you’ll say. And I agree. They could. The amount they’re TRYING to learn is sweet and overwhelming and will bring a tear to your eye, honestly. Not all of these kids, of course (the killer of Iryna Zarutska is the age of one of my kids, after all) but by and large, the decent kids of these generations are fighting like heck to patch up their knowledge and learn what should have been their civilizational birthright.
This is very easy when it comes to things like “how to repair a toilet flush mechanism” or “how to cook beef Stroggonoff” or even “how do I maintain my lawn.”
For other stuff… well, as a mostly autodidact the biggest problem is you don’t even know what you don’t know. Latin and Greek, say are easy to figure out you should know, so you could read the foundational texts of the West in the original. Learning is a little harder, because all languages are harder in isolation. (It has occurred to me I should start a study group for these on Discord. It might help me.) But the other stuff? Do you know how many times I think I’ve researched something to the Nth degree for a book, and then a beta (Or, heaven forbid, a reader after it’s published) says “Sarah, your entire second half of the book is impossible. Don’t you know that x y z didn’t happen like that/works like this?” And no. I’d never stumbled on it in years of research, and honestly had no idea I was even missing it.
When it comes to things like history though (or economics. DEAR LORD economics) the ground shifts. Yes, there’s a lot of information and 99% of it is poisonously wrong. And they came out of school without enough information to know this is crazy cakes. AND with a ground in, bone-level distrust of the institutions that taught them or employ them.
I’m now coming across videos by thirty somethings on youtube who think Tartaria and the mud floods were real and really happened and are being covered up. This is not a joke. PEOPLE BELIEVE IT. And not stupid people.
Which brings me to the point of this post, over two thousand words in. We keep saying they weren’t taught history, but this isn’t true. They were taught history. That’s why they’re in a permanent panic about Nazis and completely missidentify what Nazis were and what they did.
Look, if you don’t live with a computer person: there’s a new thing called Vibe Coding, aided by AI.
I’m not going to diss WELL DONE vibe coding (Yes it exists, and I really am not dissing it, you can sit down Matt and Ian.) My husband assures me there is such a thing (so does ESR and he should know.) and it saves you time and is amazing.
For the rest of you: it is where you give the AI code instructions in plain languate, then use the code given. (This is grossly simplified. Again, sit down Matt and Ian. I’m not TEACHING vibe coding. You want to explain it better, send me articles.) It is best applied by those who understand code, because they can see where there are bits that do nothing or are just bad, and fix it.
It’s disastrous in the hands of those who don’t know what they’re doing.
The kids, and by kids I mean anyone younger than 60 were LARGELY (in the US there remained pockets of competency) taught vibe-history.
I was, but only for the twentieth century. The rest was much deeper, though honestly I don’t even know if I was taught it deeply in school, or it just felt that way because by the end of middle school I’d run through my father’s considerable historical library both fiction and non fiction.) When I came to the states I found an incredible emphasis on bullet points, dates and names, with absolutely NO understanding of what was behind it. You learned the “points” of the declaration of independence, but not where the ideas came from, why they were codified that way, what the opposition was. NOTHING. I believe this was because it was the early eighties, and it was easier to grade multiple choice, so teaching was mangled to fit multiple choice. (I could be wrong.)
OTOH I suspect the 20th century vibe history was intentional. I remember learning that the Nazis were racists. That they killed “inferior races” (And Jews. even at the time I remember a long argument with a teacher on “How the heck can they be considered either a race or inferior. A few brave souls in my form backed me. This was in Portugal.) that they wore impeccable uniforms and were all about the public order and cleanliness. And that Nazis preferred blonds. That they had death camps. That they were very hard on criminals (defined as anyone who disobey them.) AND were nationalists. They were evil.
Meanwhile, the communists were the opposite of the Nazis, and wanted everyone to be equal and free, loved all races, and were the good guys.
Yes, the holocaust was mentioned. (Not soaked in, as it was for my kids, but mentioned.) BUT note that it was all a bolus.
Since this was vibe-history with no context, you exited school absolutely convinced that any two of the Nazi characteristics was the road to hell. If you dressed impeccably and were blond, you were probably a Nazi. If you preferred to date blonds, you were a Nazi. If you favored order and justice upon criminals you were a Nazi. If you admired the military and read military fiction or bios (guilty) you were DEFINITELY a Nazi. And if you loved your own nation, its culture, its customs, its people? NAZI. Dangerous Nazi, as you were probably just waiting to exterminate everyone else.
Meanwhile the Communists were kind of like hippies with fewer lice (maybe.) They were into free love and hated no one, and just wanted everyone to be equally rich and happy. THIS DURING AND AFTER THE STALIN PURGES.
The reason this was so badly vibe-taught-history was two fold. What the Nazis were and what they did was the result of ideas — particularly state control, eugenics and state planned economy — which were everywhere at the time. The allies were slightly less tainted than the Nazis and hadn’t reached terminal state. (Looks at Canada and Great Britain who are getting there.) You couldn’t teach how the Nazis had become what they were without indicting FDR. So instead you pointed at other, incidental characteristics, and screamed. If that failed you pointed at Hitler and said they’d elected (doubtful, it’s more complicated than that) a madman and that’s what put them over the top.
As far as I know, this is still taught exactly this way. The kids have no way WHY the Nazis were objectionable. They just know they were and these characteristics accrue. Which is why so many of the young and the infantile old lose their minds every time we have a President who loves his country or works for the benefit of his people, and double lose it if he dresses well, or is married to a blond.
Because they know nothing but the code they were handed and which they don’t understand, of COURSE they think Trump is Hitler. To understand why he isn’t they need a short course in real history.
They need a course that makes them understand that given a state for whom citizens are possessions of the state, it always ends the same way and in the same tired old atrocities, whether they call themselves Nazis or Canadians. If the state thinks of citizens as objects to be manipulated for the benefit of the ever more controlling state, sooner or later eugenics creeps in (I’m looking at you Possessed Spain) and starts batch killing the old, the poor, the lame, the weird, and yes, any minority the state designates evil-bad according to what hat the state put on that morning. No madman needed. That mind set seems to make everyone a little mad and glad to sleep walk into hell.
And this is the problem. Of all the horrible things we’ve done to the young, teaching them Vibe-history is the worst. (And now it goes all the way to the prehistory and the mythical communist, matriarchal pre-history for which there not only isn’t any proof, but there’s plenty of evidence against.)
They’re navigating this world by maps painted by a madman with his own shit on the wall of an asylum.
They don’t even know what they don’t know.
The miracle is not that so many of them sound insane. The miracle is that the MAJORITY doesn’t. For that we must thank their innate distrust of institutions.
So what can we do? Teach. Teach as much as you can, by every means you can, patiently, gently, as respectfully as you can.
Yes, we’re old and tired (even those of you in your thirties. This timeline ages a sane person) and this is a very difficult job. It’s much easier to set fire to everything and hope paradise emerges from the ashes.
I have bad news. We’re here because people have been setting fire to everything for a hundred years. At this point, it’s hard to reach beyond the ash, the cinders and the radioactive cultural waste.
More fire will do nothing except make it harder.
Yes, you can walk away. Sure. Why not. You can wash your hands of the human project and walk away.
BUT you are as human as I am. If you value any shred of humanity, or our potential, of our future, and want our descendants to have a chance? Teach.
I’m not asking you to bring an history book to every casual encounter, or to go on a long-winded rant as I tend to on this blog.
I’m asking you to try to put in a word of truth and perspective. Here and there. As opportunity offers. And if you can, incorporate it in your art, your writing, games you create, anything really to help the medicine go down. No, not preaching, just the world view.
Truth has a force of its own. And the generations after mine are starved for truth. DYING for it, sometimes literally.
Stop calling them bad names and stomping on the hands trying to grasp the top of the cliff. Help them up and teach them how to stand.
So they can walk into the future.






































































































































