
Recently, in a conversation between friends, the hypothesis was floated: what if all the burning farms, derailed trains, crop failures, etc. etc. etc. etc. ad scary nauseam aren’t really enemy action, but more a competency crisis.
As in these things happen not because big-bad is plotting against us, but because no one knows how to do the things they purportedly do anymore. Some kind of know, but they are hampered, slow, and sometimes hemmed in by counterproductive regulation or the result of previous “strokes of genius” decisions that broke the system.
I’m not going to bore anyone with what I know to be a massive crisis of competency plus inherited factors breaking ability to function in the field. I already did that at Mad Genius Club this morning, and am not unpacking the whole thing again.
But here’s the thing: All of us can live without a functioning fiction writing/selling market. Maybe not as pleasantly/happily, at least for those of us addicted to reading, but we can survive. We have old books to re-read, and if we get really desperate we can write our own fanfic.
It’s another thing when you talk of transportation or medicine, or farming, or– Well, everything else.
I have friends and fans in a lot of places. And almost everyone’s story is of being caught in the middle of a system where nobody knows or can do much of anything. It’s all the way the cogs and bureaucracy move. And the way they move is completely divorced from what needs done, or what anyone knows how to do.
To give an example: Suppose you were hired to haul buckets from a well. But when you actually get the job, you find out, no. Because of inherited systems, and what your superiors expect, you’re supposed to climb down the wall, hand over hand, and bring up water by the cupfull. And there are regulations in the works to make that by the spoonfull. However, you’ll be fully held to account if you can’t provide the amount of water the company is contracted for. You. Personally.
So, you do what you can. You fudge the books. On paper, you’re getting all this water up. Where the water goes no one knows, every one down stream (pardon the pun) from you does the same.
If this sounds like the soviet system? It is. It’s just that the directives don’t come directly and traceably from the government. (Though under the infestation of Bidentia they increasingly do.) Instead, they come from “experts” “scientists” “Studies” “marketing gurus.” And sometimes they are curtailed or made worse by agencies and regulations.
Yes, the managerial or worse “expert” class is the same that furnishes government. These are not your friends, are not meant to be your friends, and are convinced they know much more than you do.
What they know in fact is “how to manage.” But it’s not how to manage anything. They know theory of management (or whatever) derived from no reality (mostly from the writings of Marx, if you dig a little) and pushed ALL THE WAY DOWN.
It’s like — exactly like — being run by “experts” who memorized the Little Red Book. It might please those in power, but it has nothing to do with accomplishing the actual job in front of you.
Part of this has to do with colleges. Remember all those student demonstrations of the 60s? If you’re like me, and didn’t hit college till the eighties or younger, you might think these are, as the movies show, all anti-war and for civil rights, and all that jazz.
Unspoken to any of us is the fact that half of these demonstrations were to DUMB DOWN THE CURRICULUM. To demand easier grading. And social factors taken into account. And to “update” to “relevant things.”
The idea being that we were in a sort of an year zero and anything else, in the long storied glories of Western civ no longer counted, except for us to declare ourselves superior to it.
Hence, Liberal arts majors who don’t know Latin or classical history (or really any history except maybe ‘history of pop music’ and that watered down.) And economists who don’t understand the basics of economics (hello, AOC), etc. etc. etc.
It gets worse from there.
My own job ad hoc and has more or less always been self taught. But the degree I have is the closest thing to preparation for it. (If you ignore the languages part and look at the literature.) What this means is that I had to unlearn all my training before I became even passably competent.
Again, my job is non-essential. But I hear the same story from everyone Either being taught the “current thing” which is actually wrong, or being taught relatively correct things, but not what came before, so there are holes in your knowledge you don’t even know are there and don’t find out until you trip and fall headfirst into them. If you survive, you start learning. But sometimes…. well, there’s a fire or a derailment.
Now imagine that at every step of the way. Every. Step. Of. The. Way.
The problem is not that we have so many fires and destruction of infrastructure. The problem is that we’re averting maybe 9 in ten through sheer stupid luck and inertia. Which won’t last forever.
A friend was bitching about a newly-laid down road, which already had potholes. This is sort of emblematic of our situation.
My generation, and I say this as a studious kid who learned everything she could, was half taught. I’m still filling in holes in my knowledge, both of routine everyday things relating to the household, and of my job and how to do it. I’m not alone in this. I’m 60.
But I know, from reading, that my father’s generation was already, for whatever reason half-prepared. Which means I’m more like a quarter prepared. And the kids…
Well, I saw what they were teaching mine which amounted to making it impossible for them to learn anything real. So I taught them as much as I could around/over/under the school. This means they’re good on the basics. But I didn’t do their professional training. They’re trying to do that over/around/despite the schools/system. Yeah….
So, what we have is a crisis of competency. Some of it might be the end result of what happens in a top-down system, including education.
And some is the results of that maleducation. Sometimes I think the only thing preventing a total crash is that people are working later and later. That at this point that means my generation is holding up the tent is horrifying, because I know how badly prepared we are.
Ladies, gentlemen and cats — Indy is lying across my wrists and biting my knuckles as I type. Sometimes he rolls across the keyboard. It’s not why this is so late, but it’s not helping — we’re in trouble.
We keep waiting for the adults to come in and rescue us. We are the adults. See that white horse? Get on it and ride to the rescue.
Or in other terms: it is our honor and our very great privilege to be the generation with our butts in the bear trap in the crucial place at the crucial time.
You know where you’re weak and where your system of work is absurd. I know you’re tired. But you can’t say “apres moi le deluge.” It’s the future of humanity at stake. Not just the west, not just civilization. If we fall, humanity falls, and I don’t know when and if we climb again.
Learn, learn, learn. Become aware of the holes, and fill them. And teach, teach teach. Yeah, yeah, the children are the future. Only they’re now middle aged, and the future presents itself lost and uneducated. Go fix that.
Do it now. We might not have tomorrow. With incompetence winning this war, we’re skating over the abyss by our lucky charms.
And luck is an unreliable mistress.
















































































