What, drawn, and talk of peace! I hate the word,
As I hate hell, all Montagues, and thee.
Save that quote as we’ll return to it before this is over. For now let’s look at two other observations on hatred. In The Moon Is A Harsh Mistress, Heinlein says it is easier to get people to hate than to love. Easier to get them to hate the enemy than to love their country (or their ideas, or their future. Or whatever.) As we know this is correct, because the left has run on it for centuries.
Rogers and Hammerstein, who could write great songs but were no political philosophers, on the other hand, thought that hatred had to be carefully taught. This is … what’s that word? Oh, yeah: Idiotic. Humans hate as easily as they love. Both are part of the same thing: of being social apes who defend their own and protect against the enemy.
If you want to know Europe’s geography of hatred look to the borders. Where countries meet, there are battle lines, fought out and back and forth over time. And there are proverbs “From Portugal neither good demons nor good matrimony” “From Spain neither good wind nor good marriage.” Every border in Europe. (And I’ll admit that finding myself in the middle of a group of Spanish speakers makes my blood pressure rise. I think it’s because it’s so similar and yet not and I don’t understand all of it, which spikes the anxiety. This is made worse by Castellano which hisses. Look, I grew up with cats.)
Hatred like love requires proximity and pervasiveness, and that you KNOW the other people. This is why, btw, the program that I first came here under as an exchange student could only be started by Americans. Because it assumes knowing the other better causes you to love them. It’s …. not right. It’s easier to hate them, particularly if they’re similar enough to annoy you because they’re not right.
Think of hominid bands. The biggest threat was your closest neighbors, which well…. raiding and such being what it was, were probably just like you genetically.
You don’t have to be taught to hate. Hate happens when two groups, similar enough and yet different, are competing for the same resources. That’s it. Love happens in similar circumstances, where there’s no competition.
Part of the reason America managed at least SOME degree of cultural integration is that the resources were so abundant, and that it was colonized by a big lump of the same culture (two big lumps of closely related cultures, if you consider the German influx large enough) and then a lot of groups SO DIFFERENT that there was no “hook” for the hatred. They were simply too different.
(This incidentally explains why the English hate the French but LOVED the Arabs. This crazy Arabophillia wasn’t found in the peninsula where memory ran deep and there were enough remnants that Arabs were understood and different enough to be hated.)
Heck, there wasn’t a lot of hatred against the King and England in America. Probably a lot more love than hatred. Until the king started stomping around. (Hence the quip in TMIAHM which is a roman de clef of the American revolution. In TMIAHM the stomping around is provoked and calculated. It probably didn’t have to be in the revolutionary war.)
Anyway, what does this matter?
Well, first you have to understand the left runs on hatred. No, seriously.
You see, the latest incarnation of its ideology, communism, with the USSR as its flagship, imploded drastically, so they have to keep hatred flowing towards their opponents, so that its thralls don’t escape the dying vision for a vision that works.
Some of their hatred is organic. The beliefs of Marxism provide hatred and envy aplenty. After all, being an economic ignoramus but a for-real poisonous neurotic, Marx knew the reason he wasn’t king of the universe was the vast conspiracy of how society was organized. The whole “class war” thing is designated to make you hate a collective enemy. So that comes naturally to the devotees of the cult.
On top of which there’s the fact that the ideology makes perfect sense in an intellectual way “if only everybody.” If you have the type of mind that doesn’t realize that never in the history of ever has “everybody” done something, including not cutting off their own nose to spite their faces, i.e. if you life so much inside your own mind that you have no idea other people aren’t widgets, you’re going to hate people. It would be so easy if they just got with the program, abolished private property and looked after each other! Obviously their not doing it means they’re evil. You’re going to hate them. Particularly the ones you think “benefit from the system.”
So their hatred is organic, and ridiculously easy to point at whoever is the hatred of the day. The truth is they hate even the classes they’re told to love. Over my many years in the arts I met a lot of open Marxists. Become friends with one of them and behind the scene you find they hate every possible identifiable minority, as well as the majority, of course. The more new agey of them dream of “Earth changes” that will wipe out the majority of the population while leaving them (and I want to point out for disambiguation these are by and large people who need help crossing the street without a guide) both untouched and in charge. Because of course, they’re smart. (That’s the other illusion of Marxism.)
Now, the other thing you have to understand is that the left KNOWS they’re the good people. THE REALLY GOOD PEOPLE. After all, they want to share every bit of wealth and look after the disenfranchised. (Which includes them, for… reasons.) So they’re good. Their enemies, meanwhile, the ones who refuse to share and be equal, they’re evil people. Self-explanatory. Therefore, if they have all these hates…. the right must be based on MORE HATE. In fact the only reason we don’t want to share and sing Kumbaya is because we are racist, sexist, homophobic and hate EVERYONE.
The left is so sure of it that Obama’s bullshit about people in rural areas clinging to their bibles and their guns and their fear of people who aren’t like them — regurgitated stuff from college. And not deep stuff from college, mind — was kindness itself, cutting those haters some slack.
And this is why their latest attempt to destroy MAGA — a coalition that both scares them and baffles them — is trying to make us hate Jews.
Why Jews specifically is an utter puzzle, unless the whole thing is actually run by Russia, who seem to have a Jewish obsession for reasons I can’t explain without a deep history of Russia. (And I ain’t doing that.) There are indications that way. But I think it’s too simple. I mean sure, the Russians would jump after that like a rooster after a berry, but if you think the Russians are our only enemies…. well! (And I’m almost sure Obama himself was a Muslim Brotherhood construct, so they can do stuff, yes.) And most of them are — for reasons of their own — obsessed with Jew hatred. (The exception is the Chinese, for whom we’re all inferior round eyes, every single one of us.)
However, if you’re thinking that MAGA is falling apart, you must be listening to on media propaganda too much. Why? Because MAGA isn’t talking heads. MAGA isn’t the “online discussion.”
MAGA is — as I told you when all of you were sure Trump was washed up. Another such online operation before the 24 election — a thing of the rest of the country that has had enough of the democrat bullshit. (And it took them long enough to get fed up, honestly.) Making one’s own country great again shouldn’t be controversial, unless you’re a foreign invaders. So people screaming at it are self identifying, and people see that.
As I told you back in the days of “DeSantis is the new face of the right” ya, no. Stop falling for stupid propaganda. I have nothing against DeSantis (he annoys me in some ways. But in some ways he annoys me less than Trump. So.) but in the country at large, those not extremely online, he was a “Who?” which is much worse than being hated when it comes to political prospects. Yes, the extremely online left hated him. The extremely online right loved him. For the guy who came to fix my oven he was a “Who? Oh. The guy in FL. I guess he’s okay.”
The coalition wasn’t being ripped apart. Some idiots (or evil people) had convinced Ron he had a chance, so he was trying, but in the rest of the country he had no purchase. None at all. Online? Oh, hell, if you went by online commenters he was already elected president, no question.
This entire Jew hatred thing? Same thing. Exact same thing.
And part of it is that proximity thing. Look, yes, America has a lot of Jewish people. Most of the visibly different Jews, though? The identifiable Jews? Urban. (Might be genetic. Would explain why I long for the skyscrapers. ;) Note that’s a joke.) And because they’re a middleman minority, they tend to strive and get to prominent positions.
All of them? Don’t be an idiot. No, not even most of them. For some reason my Jewish friends are as broke as I am. But enough for people to be able to point to positions of prominence and see Jews in them.
Historically there’s a ton of reasons why Jews would end up in prominent positions in the 20th (and from the 18th on) centuries. Including the fact that almost all governments tried to prevent them from doing things like owning land. (There were exceptions, yes, but not worth mentioning.) And the fact that the majority they lived among could be stirred to hatred if they became too visible (see massacre of innocents, Egypt, but really, all of the middle ages.) meant that they specialized in professions that were portable. You could leave at any minute and take your knowledge with you. (Also give gold to your kids for important life events — this is a thing in my family, but I suspect it’s true in all of Portugal, honestly — because if you have to pick up and go you won’t go destitute.)
There were other reasons, like the fact most of Europe hampered itself with “Christian” laws against lending at interest. Without the Jews it’s doubtful that the renaissance could have happened.
Anyway, so the culture, as a culture — it is a culture though one with a million faces, because each small group took from the host country — was perfectly poised for industrialization and intellectual professions becoming the pinnacle of the modern world. Oh, and understood finance.
So, yes, there are a lot of Jews in visible, prominent positions. And a lot who live a day at a time and paycheck to paycheck. It doesn’t take a grand conspiracy. Just a complicated and fraught history and a stubborn streak a mile wide, which MIGHT be genetic.
Again the point/problem with that is that they’re highly visible in cities and in certain fields. (Look, bucko, if Jews really ran the world in a grand conspiracy none of them would work in publishing. Not a single one. There ain’t no money in it. There are however a lot of neurosis. Which seem to be genetic, as well but might be cultural.)
Jews are not highly visible anywhere else. They’re not highly EXISTENT anywhere else. Not as a visible cultural minority.
They exist mostly in academic settings and urban settings. There aren’t very many of them in the US. There aren’t very many of them in the world, for that matter.
So is there a great upswelling of Jew-hatred in the right in the US? No. There is Jew-hatred in Academia because they’re being carefully taught to excuse one of the most barbaric attacks of modernity and somehow blame it on the victims. And there are minorities in urban settings who’ve been taught they’re government clients and that if they don’t get their “due” it’s other minorities fault.
That’s it.
So where is the upswelling online coming from? Mostly from outside. From the left, of course, because they do hate Jews because they’re convinced all Jews are capitalists, and they hate them people with money. If only they gave everyone everything! Then they could have a paradise! And from abroad who think they can push on these divisions to stop America unflopping itself and making itself a beacon for the world. The reason they think they can push on this and make it happen is their OWN cultural blind spot.
You see very European country including (particularly?) Russia, but also most (if not all) Middle Eastern countries are ABSOLUTELY convinced that the people running the news, etc. are super smart and completely know what’s going on in their own country. Instead of, as in the US, being a minority of grifters hired for political allegiance to the left. They also think (as we’ve run into with the French gigolo who commented here once) that our media MUST be run by the government or at least controlled by it, else how would they “know what to say.”
This results in them buying every lefty narrative about the right and ALSO believing it must be much worse. (“If this is what they’re allowed to publish.”) Which means they know that half the country is racist sexist homophobic, and flying those flags is a great way to divide the right and destroy America, making it go to war against itself, particularly what the Europeans (but particularly Russians) firmly believe is the entire financial elite.
It’s an illusion chasing stupid. But it’s very loud and some of you people keep getting all nervous-nellied over it.
Go out and talk to normal people, outside college campus and outside the extremely online community. It’s nonsense.
There simply aren’t enough Jews to hate in the rest of the country. (Oh, there are plenty, they are just …. not culturally visible. They look, act and are just like everyone else, without that little bit of difference that stokes suspicion or hatred.)
And the lefty media no longer has the unified megaphone power to make Jew hatred a thing everywhere, as they would have (did have) early in the twentieth century.
And MAGA? MAGA is fine. We might occasionally get mad at Trump, but he’s better than the alternative. And if he falls, we’ll find someone who gets up the left’s nose even more. He’s not our leader. He’s our flag. Something the left utterly fails to get, because they run to “great leaders” the poor idiots.
Weirdly the Jew Hatred attempt is being run with minority flags. This is an attempted dual piece of social engineering by the left. First because they know the indoctrination in school worked and people shut down if asked to be “racists”. This might no longer be true, btw, but the left moves slowly. So if you want to stoke ethnic hatred you need to use ethnic minorities.
Second because they realize they’re in danger. Their various sympathy ploys for the illegals haven’t worked. Being idiots, they don’t realize this is not racial but cultural/situational. People don’t like illegals because they are illegal and by and large are here to TAKE ADVANTAGE of the US social net, unlike immigrants of old.
BUT the left thinks this is racism against Latins (they’ve tried to convince me of this online. It’s hilarious) so therefore they are trying to defuse that by having someone with a Spanish last name stoke up Jew hatred to redirect. The same with the black chick.
This must be sop in some old soviet agit prop book, because it’s ALWAYS one of the marks it’s an op run by that side. It just makes things weird in America, without doing what they want, but hey.
As for the Jews, my biggest problem with them is that they fell for the media psy-op when they landed in the US: the media psy-op that told them the right hated them. (Oh, some did. As did some of the left. Maybe most.) And so they are fearfully clinging to the left.
There might also be, in people who mated for intellectual excellence for a long time a touch of the ’tisms (naaaah) so they believe what the left says about themselves, and therefore they’re all for inclusiveness and love and restorative justice. Sigh.
They’re also, you have to understand this, culturally very against demonizing any group or turning against it. Possibly because they know the results of that in their own history. It’s almost like the guy who told us to love our enemies and pray for those who would hurt us was one of them. (Seriously. So annoying. Yes, I am one of his followers. But I have the right to find Him super-annoying.)
They are…. waking up. Slowly. One by one. Slightly hampered by cultural assumptions, high buy in of academia and being urban. But they are waking up.
Which probably is another reason the left is pointing at them and shrieking kill.
Look, the left is in disarray. They have no ideas. People keep defecting.
Breaking up the right is their last best hope.
It won’t work. It won’t work because you can’t break what was never one piece. The right right now is “I don’t know what I want, but it’s not what the left is offering.” That’s it.
That type of pissedoffness won’t break, because it’s not together.
When things calm down, when victory is more obvious, when being on the right has its own perks, THEN it’s time to worry about where the movement is going and try to steer it. To the extent a group of individuals who are very individual can be steered. At least keep it out of the deeper ditches, and keep the “converts” i.e. lefties from making it exactly like the left.
For now? this is the latest lefty psy-op. Best handled by laughing, calling them names and moving on.
It won’t last long. It’s already losing purchase. But it will last longer than say “the economy is dying, we must now vote left” because it’s a favorite among the left. You see, they really do hate Jews, mostly because they convinced themselves the “Palestinians” are underdogs. (That or a perpetual fascination with tyrants and destructive people.)
And now we return to the top. Peace: they hate the very word. Because they define themselves by their hatred and their opposition to something or someone.
So they must keep peace at bay by hating those they were designated to hate. Just like the whole Montague and Capulet thing. And it no doubt was very useful to the patrician of the city to have these powerful families enmeshed in endless brawling. Just like the international would-be rulers think if they only make America fall abrawling they can rule the world.
They can’t. And the fact they think they can is the measure of their lack of understanding of the world.
Don’t be like them. Be aware there is life beyond online psy ops.
Go live it a bit.
UPDATE: While I was doing yard work — I hate yard work, and I forgot to get an audio book for the mind while I did it — it came to me I’m being an idiot. This is not primarily, or possibly even, about dividing the right. Well, not for the left in the US. (The Russians are trying to put their oar in and are as usual misreading everything about the US.) No. The left thinks we hate Jews, sure. (And everyone else.) But they also think we hide it so well. Hence “dog whistles.” No. This is PRIMARILY and perhaps above all about stopping the American Jewish exodus from the democrats.
You see, they took the mask off rather dramatically after 10/7 and a lot of people woke up. A lot of them are volunteers and donors. A lot others are academics and writers. The left wants them to think the right is even MORE anti-Semitic than they are, to stop that hemorrhaging.
Extra reason for our commentariat on the right, Jewish and not, to take a deep breath and see through the psy-ops. Then point and laugh, boys, (and girls. And small winged animals.) point and laugh.